
The doctrine commonly referred to as “Once Saved, Always Saved” teaches that once a person has genuinely come to faith in Jesus Christ, their salvation is permanently secured and cannot be forfeited, regardless of future choices, behavior, or belief. According to this view, a true conversion guarantees eternal security in a way that is unaffected by subsequent disobedience, unbelief, or spiritual departure.
This position is held by many sincere and devoted Christians who desire to safeguard the assurance of salvation and magnify the grace of God. However, after careful study of Scripture, I have come to believe that the Bible presents a more relational and conditional framework. Rather than portraying salvation as a single irreversible transaction detached from future response, Scripture consistently emphasizes ongoing faith, obedience, endurance, and abiding as essential components of a living relationship with Christ. The New Testament repeatedly calls believers not only to believe, but to continue believing; not only to begin, but to endure to the end.
SALVATION
Ephesians 2:8-9 “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast.”
Before we can talk about whether someone can walk away from salvation, we first need to understand what salvation is and how we receive it. Salvation is a gift from God. We cannot earn it by being good enough, going to church enough, following enough rules, or doing enough good works. Jesus did the work we could never do for ourselves. We are saved by God’s grace through faith in Jesus Christ. There is absolutely nothing we can brag about because salvation begins with what Christ has done, not what we have done.
But saying that we are not saved by works does not mean that how we live after coming to Christ does not matter. The Bible describes real faith as something that produces change. James 2:17 says that faith without works is dead. James is not saying that our works save us. He is saying that living faith produces something. When we genuinely put our faith in Christ, that faith should begin affecting how we think, how we live, what we desire, and how we respond to God. We will not become perfect overnight, and believers can still struggle, stumble, and sin, but genuine faith is not supposed to remain nothing more than words.
A simple way to understand it is this: works are not the cause of salvation; they are the fruit of faith. We do not obey God so that we can earn salvation. We obey because we have put our faith in Christ and now belong to Him. Repentance, obedience, spiritual growth, and a changed life flow out of that relationship.
This distinction is especially important for everything that follows in this teaching. When I say that Scripture calls believers to continue in faith, abide in Christ, endure, obey, and not turn away, I am not saying that we save ourselves or earn enough points to stay saved. I am saying that the faith through which we receive God’s grace is meant to continue.
Salvation begins by grace through faith, and the Christian life continues by trusting and following Christ. We are not talking about earning salvation. We are talking about remaining in the One who saves us. That distinction is the foundation for understanding the passages we are about to look at.
EVIDENCE AGAINST ONCE SAVED ALWAYS SAVED
The Bible contains numerous passages that suggest salvation requires ongoing faith and perseverance, and that it’s possible for believers to FALL AWAY.
John 15
Throughout the book of John he uses the subject matter of submission heavily. We see that Jesus entirely submits to the Father’s will to finish His purpose, which in return, we are to entirely submit to finish our purpose. John also gives an impenetrable standpoint, being, people are either “of God” or “of the world.” This gospel also holds seven “I am” statements from Jesus, which extensively explains His identity.
This is one of the few chapters collected entirely of words ascribed to Jesus Christ. Jesus is close to being arrested, tried, and crucified. He was running out of time to teach and prepare His disciples. It was a final ‘cram session.”
John 15:1-10 '“I am the true vine, and My Father is the vinedresser. Every branch in Me that does not bear fruit He takes away; and every branch that bears fruit He prunes, that it may bear more fruit. You are already clean because of the word which I have spoken to you. Abide in Me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself, unless it abides in the vine, neither can you, unless you abide in Me. “I am the vine, you are the branches. He who abides in Me, and I in him, bears much fruit; for without Me you can do nothing. If anyone does not abide in Me, he is cast out as a branch and is withered; and they gather them and throw them into the fire, and they are burned. If you abide in Me, and My words abide in you, you will ask what you desire, and it shall be done for you. By this My Father is glorified, that you bear much fruit; so you will be My disciples. “As the Father loved Me, I also have loved you; abide in My love. If you keep My commandments, you will abide in My love, just as I have kept My Father’s commandments and abide in His love.'
Verse 1 – The True Vine
Jesus begins by saying, “I am the true vine, and My Father is the vinedresser.” The picture is actually very simple. Think about a grapevine. The branches cannot live or produce grapes by themselves. Everything they need comes through their connection to the vine. Cut a branch completely away from its source of life and eventually it dries up. Jesus says He is that source. This also connects to the Old Testament, where Israel was pictured as a vine. Israel repeatedly failed to produce the fruit God desired. Jesus now calls Himself the true vine. Our spiritual life does not come from simply belonging to a religious group, following rules, or having a Christian background. Life comes through Christ. So before Jesus ever starts talking about fruit, pruning, or removal, He establishes the foundation: the branch depends completely upon the vine. We cannot produce spiritual life independently from Jesus.
Verse 2 – The Vinedresser and the Pruning
Jesus then says the Father is the Vinedresser. In other words, the Father is the One caring for the vine and its branches. Jesus describes two kinds of branches. There are branches that do not bear fruit, and there are branches that do bear fruit. The fruitful branches are pruned so that they can become even more fruitful. Pruning is not necessarily punishment. Anyone who has worked with plants understands that sometimes healthy growth needs to be cut back so the plant can become stronger and produce more. In the same way, God works in our lives. He corrects us, removes things that hinder our growth, teaches us, and shapes us. Sometimes that process is uncomfortable, but the purpose is growth. However, Jesus also mentions branches that do not bear fruit, and He says the Father removes them. That becomes important as the illustration continues because Jesus is going to explain what happens when a branch does not remain in the vine.
Verse 3 – Cleansed but Continuing
Jesus then tells His disciples: “You are already clean because of the word which I have spoken to you.” This matters when determining who Jesus is addressing. Jesus does not describe these men as outsiders who just heard about Him. He tells them they are already clean. And remember what happened earlier. In John 13, Jesus said the disciples were clean, “but not all,” and John explains that He was referring to Judas. Judas later leaves. Now Jesus tells the remaining disciples, “You are already clean.” The important point is simply this: Jesus Himself describes these disciples as clean. And yet, after telling them they are already clean, Jesus does not tell them that nothing from this point forward matters. His very next instruction is about continuing.
Verse 4 – The Command to Abide
Jesus says: “Abide in Me, and I in you.” The word abide simply means remain, stay, continue, or dwell. That makes Jesus’ command very important. He is not telling complete outsiders, “Pretend to be connected to Me.” He is speaking to His disciples and telling them: Remain in Me. Jesus then explains why: “As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself, unless it abides in the vine, neither can you, unless you abide in Me.” A branch cannot disconnect from its source and continue producing life on its own. In the same way, Christians cannot separate themselves from Christ and expect to continue producing spiritual life. Abiding is not about earning salvation through enough good behavior. It is about remaining connected to Christ, who is the source of our spiritual life.
Verse 5 – The Evidence of Fruit
Jesus continues: “I am the vine, you are the branches.” He makes the picture even clearer. Jesus is the vine. His disciples are the branches. Then He says: “He who abides in Me, and I in him, bears much fruit.” Fruit is what naturally comes from a healthy branch connected to a healthy vine. The branch does not create life for itself. It receives life from the vine, and that life produces something visible. The same principle applies spiritually. A life connected to Christ should eventually produce evidence of that relationship. That includes things like obedience, love, repentance, spiritual growth, and the fruit of the Spirit. That does not mean Christians become perfect. Fruit grows over time. But Jesus expects the life flowing from Him to eventually become visible through the branch. Then He says: “For without Me you can do nothing.” That keeps us from turning this teaching into works-based salvation. The branch isn’t congratulating itself for producing grapes. The life came from the vine. In the same way, everything good produced in us ultimately depends upon Christ.
Verse 6 – The Warning of Removal
Now Jesus gives the serious part of the illustration: “If anyone does not abide in Me, he is cast out as a branch and is withered.” Remember what abide means: remain. Jesus is warning about not remaining. The branch is cast out, it withers, and Jesus says those branches are eventually gathered and burned. This is one of the reasons I have difficulty with the idea that salvation can never be forfeited regardless of whether someone later completely rejects Christ. Jesus gives a genuine warning about the necessity of remaining in Him. Some interpret the fruitless branches as people who were never truly saved and were only outwardly associated with Jesus. But the passage itself calls them branches “in Me” and then warns about what happens when someone does not remain in Him. Jesus does not describe the situation by saying, “They discovered that they were never branches.” His warning is: Remain in Me. That is the language we should allow to carry the weight of the passage. This also does not mean that every time a Christian sins, struggles, doubts, or goes through a spiritually dry season they have suddenly lost salvation. Jesus is talking about abiding… remaining in Him. There is a difference between stumbling while still turning toward Christ and ultimately refusing to remain with Christ.
Verse 7 – Abiding in Word and Presence
Jesus now gives us another part of what abiding looks like: “If you abide in Me, and My words abide in you…” Remaining in Jesus cannot be separated from allowing His words to remain in us. That means abiding is more than saying, “I believe in Jesus.” His teaching begins shaping how we think, what we believe, the decisions we make, and the way we live. Jesus had already explained this in John 14:23–24 when He connected loving Him with keeping His word. Jesus also connects abiding with prayer. When His words are shaping us, our desires begin changing. We start wanting what honors Him rather than simply asking God to approve everything we already want. So abiding affects not only our behavior but also our hearts, desires, and prayers.
Verse 8 – Fruit that Glorifies the Father
Jesus says: “By this My Father is glorified, that you bear much fruit; so you will be My disciples.” The purpose of fruit is ultimately to glorify God. A healthy fruit tree points to the health of the tree itself. In the same way, spiritual fruit points beyond us to the One supplying the life. That means Christian fruit is not about proving how spiritual we are. The goal isn’t for people to look at us and say, “Look how wonderful that person is.” The goal is for our lives to point back to God. Fruit also gives visible evidence of discipleship. Again, fruit does not create the connection to Christ. Fruit comes because there is life flowing through that connection.
Verse 9 – A Love Relationship
Jesus then says: “As the Father loved Me, I also have loved you; abide in My love.” This helps us understand that abiding is not cold religious rule-keeping. At the center of everything Jesus is teaching is relationship and love. Jesus loves His disciples and tells them to remain in His love. Christianity is not simply learning a list of rules and trying hard enough to follow them. We are responding to the love of Christ and living in relationship with Him. That is why the language of abiding is so fitting. Jesus isn’t saying, “Behave yourself.” He is saying: Stay with Me. Remain in Me. Live in My love.
Verse 10 – The Conditional Nature of Abiding
Jesus says, “If you keep My commandments, you will abide in My love.” The word “if” is a conditional term. It introduces responsibility. Obedience sustains abiding. Disobedience disrupts it. Jesus models this relationship through His own obedience to the Father. This conditional structure reinforces the relational nature of salvation. Abiding is not passive. It requires keeping His commandments. The pattern is clear: obedience results in continued abiding. The absence of obedience results in departure from that active fellowship.
True discipleship is not defined by a verbal confession alone but by a life marked with obedience to His commandments and a continual abiding in His Word. Jesus did not separate love from obedience. He consistently tied genuine relationship with Him to keeping His commands and honoring what He has spoken. To abide in Him is to remain under His authority, to allow His Word to shape decisions, conduct, and convictions. A disciple is not merely someone who once believed, but someone who continues believing, continues obeying, and continues remaining.
Disobedience is not abiding. When a believer knowingly lives in contradiction to Christ’s commands, that posture reflects departure, not intimacy. Occasional failure followed by repentance is part of growth, but continued disobedience without full repentance leads to spiritual barrenness. Fruitfulness flows from living connection. If that connection is neglected or rejected, fruit diminishes. Scripture’s imagery in John 15 makes this progression clear: fruitlessness leads to removal. A branch that ceases to bear fruit and does not remain in the vine is ultimately cut off. This is not a minor warning; it is a sober one.
Abiding in His love cannot be disconnected from keeping His commandments. Jesus Himself said, “If you keep My commandments, you will abide in My love.” The structure is conditional. Obedience sustains abiding. To claim to abide while resisting His authority is a contradiction. If we are not obedient, then we are not actively abiding in His love. True discipleship is demonstrated through alignment, not assertion. It is revealed through endurance, not enthusiasm alone.
The Bible repeatedly urges believers to endure, remain, and continue, language that implies salvation is not merely a one-time event but an ongoing journey of faithfulness. Jesus states plainly in Matthew 24:13, “But the one who endures to the end will be saved.” Endurance is future-oriented and conditional. Paul echoes this in Colossians 1:22–23, explaining that Christ reconciles believers “if indeed you continue in the faith, stable and steadfast, not shifting from the hope of the gospel.” The word “if” carries weight. Revelation 2:10 adds, “Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life.” Faithfulness must persist to the end.
Free will is a consistent biblical principle. Joshua 24:15 declares, “Choose this day whom you will serve.” The ability to choose implies the ability to turn. A believer is not transformed into a being incapable of rejection. Jesus warns in Matthew 7:21–23 that not everyone who calls Him “Lord” will enter the kingdom of heaven. There are those who professed His name but did not truly align their lives with His will. A person can reject God’s love through persistent unbelief or unrepentant sin.
Faith in Scripture is active and ongoing. James 2:17 reminds us that “faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead.” Living faith produces obedience. It is not static. First John 3:6 reinforces this, stating, “No one who abides in Him keeps on sinning.” This does not mean believers never stumble, but it does mean a lifestyle of continual, unrepentant sin is incompatible with abiding.
Taken together, these passages present salvation as relational and covenantal. It begins with faith, but it continues through abiding. It is sustained through obedience, endurance, and faithfulness. True discipleship is not secured by a single moment detached from future conduct. It is evidenced by a life that remains rooted in Christ, responsive to His Word, and steadfast to the end.
1 John 2:24–25
“Therefore let that abide in you which you heard from the beginning. If what you heard from the beginning abides in you, you also will abide in the Son and in the Father. And this is the promise that He has promised us—eternal life.”
To understand this passage, we need to look briefly at what John is talking about before these verses. In 1 John 2:18–23, John warns believers that there are people denying the truth about Jesus. He specifically warns about those who deny that Jesus is the Christ and says that whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either. Then, in verse 26, immediately after our passage, John says, “These things I have written to you concerning those who try to deceive you.” So John is writing to believers who are being exposed to false teaching, and his message to them is basically: Do not leave the truth about Jesus that you received from the beginning. Stay with what you were taught.
That brings us to verse 24: “Therefore let that abide in you which you heard from the beginning.” What they “heard from the beginning” is the truth about Jesus they had originally received. John is telling them not to abandon that message for some new teaching being presented to them. And notice that John tells them to “let” it abide in them. In simple terms, let it remain in you. Hold onto it. Do not move away from it.
John then says: “If what you heard from the beginning abides in you, you also will abide in the Son and in the Father.” There is that word again: if. John connects the truth remaining in them with them remaining in the Son and the Father. He does not tell these believers that it does not matter what they believe from this point forward because their relationship with God can never be affected. He warns them against deception and tells them to continue in the truth they originally received.
This is very similar to what Jesus taught in John 15. Jesus said, “Abide in Me.” Now John tells believers to let the truth they received about Christ abide in them, and if it does, they will abide in the Son and in the Father. Again, abiding means remaining. John is talking about continuing in the truth about Christ rather than abandoning it.
Then verse 25 says: “And this is the promise that He has promised us—eternal life.” This is what makes the passage especially important when talking about salvation and perseverance. The subject is not something small. John has just talked about remaining in the Son and the Father, and then he points directly to God’s promise of eternal life. Eternal life is God’s promise, not something we earn through our performance. The point is that eternal life is found in the Son, and John is warning believers not to abandon the truth about the Son.
This becomes even clearer later in the same letter. First John 5:11–12 says that God has given us eternal life and that “this life is in His Son.” John then says, “He who has the Son has life; he who does not have the Son of God does not have life.” That helps explain the importance of abiding. Eternal life cannot be separated from Jesus because eternal life is in Jesus. The issue is not that we earn eternal life by successfully abiding long enough. The issue is that we must not abandon the Son in whom eternal life is found. That is why this passage fits so well after John 15.
- Jesus says: Remain in Me.
- John says: Let the truth you received remain in you. If it remains in you, you will remain in the Son and the Father.
- And then: This is His promise to use… eternal life.
So once again, we see that continuing matters. John is writing to believers who are being confronted with false teaching and deception, and he does not tell them that their future response to Christ is irrelevant. He tells them to remain in what they received from the beginning.
First John 2:24–25 therefore reinforces the same principle we saw in John 15: remain in Christ. Eternal life is not something we earn through our works, but neither is eternal life something separate from Jesus Himself. God has placed life in His Son. Therefore, continuing in the Son matters. The message is simple: Hold onto the truth about Jesus that you received. Do not allow false teaching to move you away from Him. Let His truth remain in you, remain in the Son and the Father, and remember that the promise found in Him is eternal life.
Hebrews 3:12–14
“Beware, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief in departing from the living God; but exhort one another daily, while it is called ‘Today,’ lest any of you be hardened through the deceitfulness of sin. For we have become partakers of Christ if we hold the beginning of our confidence steadfast to the end.”
To understand this warning, we first need to understand what the writer has been talking about. Hebrews 3 takes us back to Israel after God delivered them from Egypt. These were people who had witnessed the power of God, experienced His deliverance, crossed the Red Sea, and followed Him into the wilderness. Yet even after everything they had experienced, many of them eventually hardened their hearts and refused to continue trusting God. Hebrews quotes Psalm 95: “Today, if you will hear His voice, do not harden your hearts.” The writer is using Israel as a warning. In simple terms, he is saying, do not repeat what they did. They experienced God’s deliverance, but when difficulty and testing came, they allowed unbelief to take over and their hearts became hardened.
That is the context when we reach verse 12: “Beware, brethren.” The word “brethren” is important. This warning is being given to the believing community. The writer is not addressing people who know nothing about God and telling them not to leave someone they never knew. He is warning his brothers and sisters to be careful about something that could happen among them: “lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief in departing from the living God.”
The main danger being addressed here is unbelief. This does not mean that having a question, experiencing doubt, struggling spiritually, or going through a difficult season means someone has departed from God. Israel’s example shows something much deeper. Their unbelief became a settled refusal to trust God. They repeatedly resisted Him despite everything He had shown them and done for them. Their hearts became hardened against Him.
The wording “departing from the living God” is also important. To depart means to turn away, withdraw, or leave. The Greek word used here is aphistēmi, which carries the idea of withdrawing or departing and is related to the idea behind apostasy. The writer does not say, “Be careful that you do not discover that you were never actually connected to God.” He warns them about departing from the living God. There is movement in the warning. Someone who was walking toward and trusting God can allow unbelief to grow until they begin moving away from Him.
Verse 13 then helps us understand how a person can reach that condition: “lest any of you be hardened through the deceitfulness of sin.” I think this is incredibly important because hardening usually does not happen overnight. Sin is described as deceitful because sin lies to us. It tells us something is harmless. It tells us repentance can wait. It tells us continued disobedience is not that serious. It convinces us that we can continually resist God’s correction without anything changing inside of us. But every time someone continually refuses God’s conviction and correction, the heart can become a little less sensitive to Him.
That gives us a progression in this passage. Sin deceives us, continued resistance hardens the heart, a hardened heart produces deeper unbelief, and unbelief can eventually lead someone to depart from the living God. That is why the writer tells believers to “exhort one another daily.” We need one another. Sometimes another believer can recognize that we are becoming spiritually cold, hardened, deceived, or distant before we recognize it ourselves. Encouragement, correction, accountability, prayer, and reminding one another of truth are part of helping each other continue faithfully with Christ.
Then verse 14 says, “For we have become partakers of Christ if we hold the beginning of our confidence steadfast to the end.” The phrase “partakers of Christ” is strong language. A partaker is someone who shares in or participates in something. This same word becomes important later in Hebrews 6 when the writer describes people as having become “partakers of the Holy Spirit.” Hebrews is not using distant language here. It is talking about participation in Christ.
Then we come to another important word: “if.” The writer says, “we have become partakers of Christ if we hold…steadfast to the end.” The writer has just told his “brethren” to beware of developing an unbelieving heart that causes them to “depart from the living God,” and then he connects being a partaker of Christ with holding firmly to the end. The emphasis throughout the passage is continuation!!!
The issue here is not earning salvation through works; the issue is continuing in faith rather than abandoning faith. That is exactly why Israel is being used as the example. Their fundamental problem was not that they failed to perform enough good works to earn God’s favor. Their problem was unbelief. They stopped trusting God, hardened themselves against Him, and refused to continue faithfully with Him.
This fits naturally with what we have already learned about abiding. John uses the language “remain.” Hebrews uses the language “hold fast” and warns about “departing.” The wording is different, but the message is very similar: continue in faith. Do not allow sin to deceive you until your heart becomes hardened. Do not continually resist God until unbelief takes root. And do not allow that unbelief to eventually lead you into departing from the living God.
Hebrews 3 is also not teaching that Christians should live terrified that one failure, one sin, or one doubt means they have lost salvation. That is not the progression being described. There is a major difference between a believer who stumbles, recognizes their sin, repents, and continues following Christ and someone who continually resists God until their heart becomes hardened in unbelief and they turn away from Him.
The warning is serious, but it is also simple: guard your heart. Sin can deceive you. Continued resistance can harden you. Encourage one another while it is still called “Today.” Keep trusting Christ, and hold firmly to Him to the end.
Hebrews 6:4-6
'For it is impossible for those who were once enlightened, and have tasted the heavenly gift, and have become partakers of the Holy Spirit, and have tasted the good word of God and the powers of the age to come, if they fall away, to renew them again to repentance, since they crucify again for themselves the Son of God, and put Him to an open shame.'
To understand this warning, we first need to understand what is happening before Hebrews 6:4–6. The writer does not suddenly stop and introduce a random discussion about falling away. Beginning in Hebrews 5:11, he is confronting people who should have been growing spiritually but had instead become “dull of hearing.” He tells them that by this point they should have been able to teach others, yet they still needed someone to teach them the basic principles of God’s Word again. In other words, they had been around the truth long enough that they should have been growing, but instead of progressing, they were regressing. He compares them to people who should be eating solid food by now but still need milk (Hebrews 5:11–14).
That leads directly into Hebrews 6. The chapter begins with “therefore,” which connects what he is about to say with what he has just told them. Hebrews 6:1 says, “let us go on to perfection,” or maturity. He then lists foundational teachings such as repentance, faith toward God, baptisms, laying on of hands, resurrection, and eternal judgment. His point is not that these teachings are unimportant. His point is that they are the foundation, and eventually you are supposed to build upon the foundation. You do not keep laying the foundation of a house over and over without ever building the rest of the house. These believers were supposed to continue growing and maturing in Christ.
This warning also fits something that has been building throughout Hebrews. Earlier, Hebrews 2:1 tells them to pay careful attention to what they have heard “lest we drift away.” Then Hebrews 3:12 warns the “brethren” about developing “an evil heart of unbelief in departing from the living God.” Hebrews 3:13 warns them about becoming “hardened through the deceitfulness of sin,” and Hebrews 3:14 says, “we have become partakers of Christ if we hold the beginning of our confidence steadfast to the end.” There is a progression developing throughout the letter. Do not drift. Do not allow sin to harden your heart. Do not allow unbelief to cause you to depart from God. Hold firmly to Christ and continue toward maturity.
It is in that context that we arrive at the severe warning of Hebrews 6:4–6.
The language used to describe these people is extremely important. These are not simply people who walked into church once, heard a sermon, and went home. The writer begins by saying they were “once enlightened.” To be enlightened means they had received light concerning the truth. Hebrews actually uses this language again later. Hebrews 10:32 tells the readers, “Recall the former days in which, after you were illuminated,” or enlightened, “you endured a great struggle with sufferings.” There, being enlightened is connected with their earlier Christian experience and the suffering they endured afterward. So when Hebrews 6 says these people were “once enlightened,” we should not casually reduce that to someone simply hearing information about Christianity. They had encountered and understood the truth.
Next, the writer says they had “tasted the heavenly gift.” Sometimes the word “tasted” is used to argue that these people only sampled Christianity but never truly experienced it. But Hebrews itself shows us that “tasted” does not necessarily mean a shallow or incomplete experience. Hebrews 2:9 says that Jesus “tasted death for everyone.” Jesus did not merely sample death or come close to dying. He genuinely experienced death. So we cannot assume that “tasted the heavenly gift” means these people stood on the outside and got a tiny sample of something they never actually experienced.
Then the writer gives an even stronger description: they had become “partakers of the Holy Spirit.” This is one of the most important phrases in the entire passage. A partaker is someone who shares in or participates in something. Hebrews uses this same language elsewhere. Hebrews 3:1 calls believers “partakers of the heavenly calling,” and Hebrews 3:14 says, “we have become partakers of Christ.” So when Hebrews 6 says these people became “partakers of the Holy Spirit,” the wording describes participation and sharing. The text does not just say they watched the Holy Spirit work in someone else, attended a church where the Spirit was moving, or stood around Christians who possessed the Spirit. It says they themselves became partakers of the Holy Spirit.
They had also “tasted the good word of God.” Again, the writer is describing people who had experienced the truth and goodness of God’s Word. Then he says they had experienced “the powers of the age to come.” This points to the powerful works of God associated with His kingdom. When we put all of these descriptions together, the picture becomes very strong. They had been enlightened, tasted the heavenly gift, become partakers of the Holy Spirit, experienced the good Word of God, and experienced the powers of God’s kingdom.
We have to allow the full weight of those descriptions to stand. These people are not described as casual observers or superficial hearers. These were people who had genuinely participated in the blessings of the Christian faith and experienced the work of the Holy Spirit. If someone wants to argue that these people were never genuinely saved, then these descriptions still have to be explained, especially the statement that they had become “partakers of the Holy Spirit.”
Then comes the warning: “if they fall away.” This is not talking about a Christian committing a sin, struggling with temptation, wrestling with doubt, going through a spiritually dry season, or stumbling badly and then repenting. The falling away described here is apostasy—a decisive turning away from Christ after experiencing the realities that were just described.
That distinction is extremely important because Hebrews 6 should never be used to convince a struggling Christian that because they sinned, God will never receive them again. Scripture repeatedly shows people failing, repenting, and being restored. Peter denied Jesus three times, yet Peter was restored. Failure is not automatically apostasy. There is a major difference between stumbling while still turning toward Jesus and deliberately repudiating Jesus Himself.
The writer then says it is impossible “to renew them again to repentance.” The word “again” deserves attention because it naturally points backward. The writer is speaking about renewing someone again to repentance, which raises an obvious question: why use the word “again” if there was never any previous repentance to begin with? At the very least, the wording points us toward something that had previously been experienced and is now being rejected.
The rest of the sentence helps us understand why this condition is so serious. The writer says they are “crucifying again for themselves the Son of God” and putting Him “to an open shame.” The picture is not of someone crying out, “Jesus, I want You. Please forgive me,” while Jesus refuses to receive them. That is not what is happening here. The person being described is repudiating the very Christ through whom repentance and forgiveness are available. They have turned against the One they once confessed and are now identifying themselves with His rejection.
This is why the warning carries so much weight. Hebrews has already warned about drifting away, becoming hardened through sin, developing an unbelieving heart, departing from the living God, and failing to hold firmly to Christ. Now Hebrews 6 shows us where that road can ultimately lead if someone continues down it: complete apostasy. It is not describing one mistake. It is describing the devastating end of a heart that ultimately turns away from Christ.
The verses immediately following this warning make the picture even clearer. Hebrews 6:7–8 compares people to land that repeatedly receives rain. One field receives the rain and produces useful vegetation, while another receives the rain and produces thorns. One receives blessing, while the other ends in burning. Both receive the rain, but what they ultimately produce is very different. The illustration continues the warning that what someone does with what they have received matters.
Then Hebrews 6:9 says, “But, beloved, we are confident of better things concerning you, yes, things that accompany salvation, though we speak in this manner.” Notice that after giving this severe warning, the writer calls his readers “beloved.” He is confident of better things for them. In other words, he does not believe they have already reached the condition he has just described. He warns them about apostasy while encouraging them that he expects something better from them.
Hebrews 6:11–12 continues by saying that he wants each of them to show diligence “until the end” and to imitate those who “through faith and patience inherit the promises.” Once again, Hebrews comes back to the same theme: continue, endure, hold fast, and remain faithful.
This is why I do not believe Hebrews 6:4–6 can simply be dismissed by saying these people were never genuinely involved with Christ at all. The writer deliberately describes them as enlightened, having tasted the heavenly gift, partakers of the Holy Spirit, having experienced the good Word of God and the powers of the coming age, and then speaks about them falling away. If the writer intended us to understand them as people who had never genuinely participated in the Christian life in any meaningful way, then we still have to explain why he uses such incredibly strong language about what they had experienced.
At the same time, Hebrews 6 does not teach that Christians lose salvation every time they sin. That would completely miss what the writer is describing. There is a tremendous difference between stumbling and apostasy, weakness and repudiation, having a doubt and rejecting the Savior, falling down in the race and abandoning the race altogether. A Christian can stumble and still turn toward Christ in repentance. Apostasy is turning away from Christ Himself.
Hebrews 6 therefore fits the larger biblical picture we have already been seeing. Salvation begins entirely by the grace of God and is received through faith. We do not earn salvation, and we do not maintain it by accumulating enough good works. But Scripture still repeatedly commands those who believe to continue believing, remain in Christ, hold fast, endure, and not turn away. Those warnings matter because our continued faith in Christ matters.
The message of Hebrews 6 is not, “If you mess up badly enough, Jesus will never forgive you.” The warning is much more serious than that: do not allow sin, hardening, and unbelief to carry you to the point where you completely turn away from the Christ you once knew and experienced. Hold fast to Him, continue in faith, and do not abandon the One in whom salvation is found.
Hebrews 10:26-29
'For if we sin willfully after we have received the knowledge of the truth, there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins, but a certain fearful expectation of judgment, and fiery indignation which will devour the adversaries. Anyone who has rejected Moses’ law dies without mercy on the testimony of two or three witnesses. Of how much worse punishment, do you suppose, will he be thought worthy who has trampled the Son of God underfoot, counted the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified a common thing, and insulted the Spirit of grace? '
To understand this warning, we first need to understand what the writer has been talking about. Hebrews 10 spends a lot of time explaining the difference between the sacrifices of the old covenant and the sacrifice of Jesus. Under the old covenant, sacrifices had to be offered repeatedly. Jesus, however, offered Himself once for sins. His sacrifice is sufficient. There does not need to be another sacrifice because Jesus accomplished what the old sacrifices could never fully accomplish (Hebrews 10:1–18). That becomes extremely important when the writer later says, “there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins.” He has already established that Jesus is the final and sufficient sacrifice.
Then, beginning in Hebrews 10:19, the writer turns directly to the Christian community and says, “Therefore, brethren.” He tells them that they have “boldness to enter the Holiest by the blood of Jesus.” He tells them to “draw near” with a sincere heart and full assurance of faith. Then Hebrews 10:23 tells them, “Let us hold fast the confession of our hope without wavering.” Notice again the language of continuing. They already have a confession, and now they are being told to hold onto it.
Hebrews 10:24–25 continues by telling these believers to encourage one another, stir one another toward love and good works, and not abandon gathering together. They needed one another because continuing faithfully with Christ mattered. Then verse 26 begins with the word “for.” That means the warning that follows is connected to what he has just said. Hold fast your confession. Encourage one another. Do not abandon gathering together. For if we sin willfully after receiving the knowledge of the truth, there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins.
The phrase “if we” deserves attention. The writer does not suddenly change the conversation and say, “Now let me tell you what happens to those unbelievers out there.” He includes himself in the warning: “if we sin willfully.” Throughout Hebrews, the writer repeatedly uses words such as “we,” “us,” “brethren,” and “beloved” while giving these warnings. Why? Because the warning is being spoken within the believing community.
However, we need to be very careful with the phrase “sin willfully.” This passage is not saying that every time a Christian knowingly commits a sin, they immediately lose salvation and can never be forgiven again. If that were the meaning, there would be very little hope for any Christian because believers sometimes knowingly disobey God. The rest of the passage tells us what kind of willful sin the writer actually has in mind.
By the time we reach verse 29, the person is described as having “trampled the Son of God underfoot,” treated “the blood of the covenant” as a common thing, and “insulted the Spirit of grace.” This is much bigger than someone stumbling into sin and later repenting. This is rejection of Christ Himself. Just like we saw in Hebrews 6, the issue is ultimately apostasy—a deliberate turning against Christ and the covenant after receiving the truth.
This also helps us understand the statement “there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins.” The writer is not saying that Jesus’ blood suddenly becomes incapable of forgiving someone who genuinely repents. Remember what the entire chapter has just established: Jesus is the sacrifice for sin. There is no second Messiah waiting somewhere else. There is no other covenant, no other Savior, and no other blood that can take away sin. So if someone deliberately rejects Christ and His sacrifice, what sacrifice is left for them? None. They are rejecting the only sacrifice through which forgiveness is available.
Then we come to the phrase “after we have received the knowledge of the truth.” And verse 29 gives us much stronger language. It speaks about “the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified.” Earlier in the very same chapter, Hebrews 10:10 says, “we have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all.” Hebrews 10:14 also speaks about those who are “being sanctified.” So when verse 29 describes someone in connection with “the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified,” we should take that wording seriously. This is much stronger than simply saying someone knew facts about Christianity.
To “trample the Son of God underfoot” is extremely strong language. This is not a person struggling with temptation and saying, “Jesus, please help me.” This is someone treating Christ with contempt. Likewise, treating His covenant blood as “common” means treating the blood that established the new covenant as though it were ordinary and without sacred value. Then the person is described as having “insulted the Spirit of grace.” The picture is one of deliberate rejection, not ordinary Christian weakness.
The comparison with Moses makes the warning even more serious. Under the old covenant, deliberately rejecting God’s law carried severe consequences. The writer’s argument is basically this: if rejecting the old covenant was serious, how much more serious is deliberately rejecting the Son of God and the blood of the new covenant? The new covenant is greater, Christ is greater, and His sacrifice is greater. Therefore, deliberately rejecting Him is not something small. The consequence described is “a certain fearful expectation of judgment.” That is important. The writer does not say that someone can completely reject Christ and the only consequence will be losing some rewards or experiencing less fellowship with God. The warning is about judgment. Hebrews 10:30–31 continues by saying, “The Lord will judge His people,” and then, “It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God.” This is intentionally serious language.
But just like we saw in Hebrews 6, the writer does not believe his readers have already reached this point. After giving them this severe warning, he reminds them of their earlier faithfulness. Hebrews 10:32 tells them, “Recall the former days in which, after you were illuminated, you endured a great struggle with sufferings.” They had suffered because of their faith. They had publicly identified themselves with other believers who were suffering, and they had even accepted the loss of their possessions because they knew they had something better and lasting (Hebrews 10:32–34).
Then Hebrews 10:35 tells these same people, “Therefore do not cast away your confidence.” They possess confidence, and the writer tells them not to throw it away. Hebrews 10:36 then says, “For you have need of endurance.” Again, the Christian life is not being presented as something where only the beginning matters. These believers are being told that they need to continue and endure.
The chapter then reaches an incredibly important conclusion in Hebrews 10:38–39: “Now the just shall live by faith; but if anyone draws back, My soul has no pleasure in him.” Then the writer encourages them by saying, “But we are not of those who draw back to perdition, but of those who believe to the saving of the soul.” Notice the two directions being described. There is drawing back, and there is continuing to believe. The writer is confident that his readers will continue in faith, but his confidence does not make the warning meaningless. He encourages them precisely because they need to continue. Hebrews does not say, “It does not matter what happens from here because your beginning settled everything regardless of your future response.” It repeatedly tells believers to hold fast, endure, believe, and not draw back.
So Hebrews 10:26–29 is not teaching that one intentional sin instantly causes a Christian to lose salvation. That is not the kind of willful sin being described. The passage is describing something much more severe: a person deliberately repudiating Christ after receiving the truth, treating His covenant blood with contempt, and insulting the Spirit of grace. There is a major difference between struggling with sin and rejecting Christ, falling and refusing to get back up, weakness and apostasy. A Christian who sins and then turns back toward Jesus in repentance is not doing what Hebrews 10 describes. The person in this warning is turning against the very Savior through whom repentance and forgiveness are available.
This passage fits perfectly with the warnings we have already seen in Hebrews. Hebrews 2 warns about drifting away. Hebrews 3 warns about departing from the living God through unbelief. Hebrews 6 warns about falling away. And now Hebrews 10 warns about drawing back after receiving the truth. The language changes, but the repeated message is clear: do not abandon Christ. The warning is not, “If you mess up, God is finished with you.” The warning is: do not deliberately reject the only Savior through whom forgiveness is available. Do not trample underfoot the Christ whose blood established the covenant. Do not turn away from the faith you have received. Hold fast to your confession, continue in faith, and endure to the end.
2 Peter 2:20-22
'For if, after they have escaped the pollutions of the world through the knowledge of the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, they are again entangled in them and overcome, the latter end is worse for them than the beginning. For it would have been better for them not to have known the way of righteousness, than having known it, to turn from the holy commandment delivered to them. But it has happened to them according to the true proverb: “A dog returns to his own vomit,” and, “a sow, having washed, to her wallowing in the mire.”'
Let’s first understand who Peter is talking about. Second Peter 2 is largely a warning about false teachers. Peter says they secretly bring in destructive teachings, exploit people, live corruptly, and lead others into sin. So we should not pull verses 20–22 out of that context. Peter is describing people who have ended up in serious rebellion and are now influencing others to do the same.
Peter says, “after they have escaped the pollutions of the world through the knowledge of the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.” These people had been in the corruption of the world, and Peter says they “escaped” it. He also tells us how that escape happened: “through the knowledge of the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.” That wording is especially worth noticing because Peter uses very similar language elsewhere in the same letter. In 2 Peter 1:2, he writes, “Grace and peace be multiplied to you in the knowledge of God and of Jesus our Lord.” Then 2 Peter 1:3 says God’s divine power has given believers what they need for life and godliness “through the knowledge of Him who called us.” So when Peter later describes people who “escaped the pollutions of the world through the knowledge of the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ,” we should not automatically assume that “knowledge” means they only learned some facts about Jesus.
In fact, Peter uses the language of escape earlier in the letter as well. Second Peter 1:4 speaks about believers having “escaped the corruption that is in the world through lust.” Then in 2 Peter 2:20, Peter says these people had “escaped the pollutions of the world through the knowledge of the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.” The similarity deserves attention. Peter is using very strong language to describe something that had actually happened in their lives.
Then something changes. Peter says they become “again entangled in them and overcome.” The word “again” matters because it describes a return. They escaped something, and now they have become entangled in it again. They are not simply tempted by their old life. They become entangled and overcome by it. That is why Peter says, “the latter end is worse for them than the beginning.” There is a before, an escape, and then a return. Their final condition is actually described as worse than where they originally started. Peter then makes an incredibly serious statement: “For it would have been better for them not to have known the way of righteousness, than having known it, to turn from the holy commandment delivered to them.”
Again, notice what he just said. They knew the way of righteousness, and then they turned from it. Peter does not describe people who simply heard Christianity preached and rejected it immediately. They knew the way of righteousness, and something happened afterward: they turned away from what had been delivered to them. Peter says it would actually have been better for them never to have known the way of righteousness than to know it and then turn away. That tells us something about accountability. Receiving truth and then deliberately rejecting that truth is serious. Greater knowledge brings greater responsibility.
This fits the pattern we have already been seeing throughout the New Testament. Hebrews warns about departing from the living God. Hebrews 6 warns about falling away. Hebrews 10 warns about drawing back. John speaks about not abiding. Here Peter speaks about people who escaped, became again entangled, and turned from the way of righteousness. Once again, the language describes movement away from something previously received.
Then Peter finishes with two very graphic proverbs: “A dog returns to his own vomit,” and “a sow, having washed, to her wallowing in the mire.” The is intentionally disgusting because Peter wants us to understand how serious this return is. The dog goes back to what it had vomited up, and the pig that had been washed goes right back into the mud. Both pictures describe returning to the very corruption that had been left behind.
The animal’s nature is not the only thing Peter emphasizes in the surrounding verses. Before giving the proverbs, Peter has already told us that these people escaped the pollutions of the world through the knowledge of Jesus Christ, became again entangled, were overcome, had known the way of righteousness, and then turned from it. The sow is also specifically described as “having washed.” Something had happened before it returned to the mud. What we gather from the entire passage: escape, knowledge of Christ, re-entanglement, being overcome, knowing the way of righteousness, and then turning away from it.
Galatians 5:4
'You have become estranged from Christ, you who attempt to be justified by law; you have fallen from grace.
To understand how serious this statement is, we need to understand what was happening in the churches of Galatia. Paul had preached the gospel to these people, and they had believed in Jesus Christ. But false teachers had come in and were convincing them that faith in Christ was not enough. In particular, they were teaching that Gentile believers needed to be circumcised and come under the Mosaic law. In other words, instead of relying completely upon what Jesus had done, they were being persuaded that they also needed the law in order to be right with God.
Paul is extremely direct about this throughout Galatians. Earlier, in Galatians 3:2, he asks them, “Did you receive the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?” That question is important because Paul is not speaking to people who merely heard about Christianity from a distance. He speaks to people who had received the Spirit through faith. Then in Galatians 3:3 he asks, “Having begun in the Spirit, are you now being made perfect by the flesh?” In simple terms, Paul is asking them: You started through faith and the work of the Spirit, so why are you now trying to finish through human effort?
This is the larger problem behind Galatians 5:4. He is dealing with something much deeper: changing the very basis upon which someone expects to be justified before God. They had begun by trusting Christ, but now they were being persuaded to place their confidence in keeping the law. That is why Galatians 5 begins so strongly. Galatians 5:1 says, “Stand fast therefore in the liberty by which Christ has made us free, and do not be entangled again with a yoke of bondage.” Notice the language: stand fast and do not become entangled again. Christ had brought them into freedom, and Paul is warning them not to go back into bondage.
Then Paul addresses circumcision specifically. Galatians 5:2 says, “If you become circumcised, Christ will profit you nothing.” Paul is not saying that the physical act of circumcision itself magically separates someone from Christ. Paul himself was circumcised. The issue is why they were doing it. These Gentile believers were being persuaded to receive circumcision because they believed it was necessary for justification. That meant they were no longer relying upon Christ alone.
Paul continues in Galatians 5:3 by saying that the person who takes this route becomes “a debtor to keep the whole law.” You cannot choose the law as the basis of your justification and then only keep the parts you want. If you are going to stand before God on the basis of law-keeping, then you place yourself under the obligation of the law. Then comes verse 4: “You have become estranged from Christ, you who attempt to be justified by law; you have fallen from grace.” The phrase “estranged from Christ” is extremely strong. The Greek verb Paul uses is the idea of being severed, separated, or brought away from something. Paul is not treating their change in belief as a harmless theological disagreement. Their understanding of justification affects their relationship with Christ because they are turning away from trusting what Christ accomplished and attempting to establish righteousness another way.
Then Paul says, “you have fallen from grace.” Notice that he does not say they never encountered grace. He describes movement away from grace. They had received the gospel of grace, but now they were being persuaded to abandon grace as the basis of their justification and return to reliance upon law. In context, falling from grace is not primarily about someone behaving badly. Ironically, these people were trying to become more religious. Their problem was that they were beginning to trust their religious performance as necessary for being justified before God. That gives us an important lesson about grace. Grace is not opposed to obedience; grace is opposed to earning. Christians are absolutely called to obey God, but our obedience is never the basis upon which God declares us righteous. Jesus is. The moment we begin saying, “Christ’s work is not enough; I also need this religious work in order to be justified,” we have changed the foundation of our trust.
This is why Paul takes the issue so seriously. The problem is ultimately a change in what they are trusting for salvation. They had begun through faith in Christ, received the Spirit through faith, and experienced the freedom Christ provided. Now they were being tempted to move away from reliance upon Christ and place their confidence in the law. Paul then contrasts the two approaches in Galatians 5:5: “For we through the Spirit eagerly wait for the hope of righteousness by faith.” That is where Paul wants them to remain: in faith, depending upon Christ, through the Spirit. The answer to legalism is not lawlessness. The answer is continuing to trust Christ rather than attempting to justify ourselves.
This passage fits naturally with the other warnings we have already looked at, but it gives us another side of the issue. Hebrews warns about unbelief and apostasy. John warns about not abiding. Second Peter warns about returning to corruption. Galatians warns about abandoning grace by changing the basis of our justification.
Galatians 5:4 also shows why perseverance does not mean “work hard enough to keep yourself saved.” That would actually move us toward the very error Paul is confronting. Our confidence must remain in Jesus Christ. We begin by grace through faith, and we continue depending upon grace through faith. Our works do not replace Christ at the beginning, and they do not replace Christ later. So when Paul says “you have become estranged from Christ” and “you have fallen from grace,” the warning is serious. He is telling people who had begun in the Spirit not to abandon reliance upon Christ and attempt to establish their standing before God through the law.
The message is simple: do not move your trust away from Jesus. Do not begin by faith and then try to finish through human effort. Do not exchange grace for self-justification. Christ is enough. Stand firm in the freedom He has given you, and continue depending upon Him.
Colossians 1:21–23
“And you, who once were alienated and enemies in your mind by wicked works, yet now He has reconciled in the body of His flesh through death, to present you holy, and blameless, and above reproach in His sight—if indeed you continue in the faith, grounded and steadfast, and are not moved away from the hope of the gospel which you heard.”
Colossians 1 is heavily focused on who Jesus is and what Jesus has accomplished. Paul explains that Jesus is the image of the invisible God, that everything was created through Him and for Him, that He is before all things, that everything holds together through Him, and that He is the head of the church (Colossians 1:15–18). Then Paul begins talking about reconciliation. Colossians 1:20 says that God made “peace through the blood of His cross.” So from the beginning, Paul makes it clear that reconciliation with God comes through Jesus Christ and what He accomplished on the cross, not through our own efforts.
Then Paul makes it personal. He says, “And you…” He is no longer simply explaining reconciliation as a general truth. He applies it directly to the Colossian believers and tells them what had happened to them.
First, Paul tells them what they used to be: “alienated and enemies in your mind by wicked works.” They had been separated from God and living in hostility toward Him. That was their former condition. But then Paul says, “yet now He has reconciled.” There is a clear change. They were alienated, but now they have been reconciled.
That wording is important when we ask who Paul is talking to. He does not say these people only heard about reconciliation. He does not say reconciliation was simply available to them. He says Christ had reconciled them. So we have a very simple picture: they were alienated from God, but now they have been reconciled to God through Christ.
Paul also tells us exactly how that reconciliation happened: “in the body of His flesh through death.” Their reconciliation rests entirely upon the death of Jesus. They did not reconcile themselves to God by becoming good enough, keeping enough rules, or performing enough religious works. Jesus accomplished the work of reconciliation through His own death. That keeps this passage firmly grounded in grace. Paul then explains where that reconciliation is headed. Christ’s purpose is “to present you holy, and blameless, and above reproach in His sight.” There is almost a timeline in the passage. They were alienated, they have now been reconciled, and Christ intends ultimately to present them holy, blameless, and above reproach before God. We have their past condition, their present reconciliation, and the future goal.
Then Paul says something extremely important: “if indeed you continue in the faith.” That little word “if” once again matters.
Paul does not say, “You have been reconciled, so whether you continue believing from this point forward does not matter.” Instead, he connects their future presentation before God with continuing in the faith. The people being told to continue are the same people Paul has just said were reconciled. The “you” who were once alienated are the “you” who have now been reconciled, and they are the same “you” who are told to continue in faith.
That is important because sometimes this passage is explained by saying, “If someone does not continue, that simply proves they were never really reconciled in the first place.” But that is not how Paul describes his readers, at all. He does not say, “Some of you might only appear reconciled.” He tells them, “now He has reconciled” you, and then tells those same people, “if indeed you continue in the faith.” Whatever conclusion we reach about salvation and perseverance, we need to allow both statements to stand.
Paul then explains what continuing looks like by saying “grounded and steadfast.” In simple terms, he is talking about stability. Think about a house with a solid foundation. When storms come, the goal is for that house to remain standing rather than being moved from its foundation. In the same way, Paul wants these believers firmly planted in their faith in Christ rather than being easily pulled away by something else.
Then he says, “and are not moved away from the hope of the gospel which you heard.” Again, notice the language of movement. Paul tells people who have been reconciled not to be moved away from the hope they received through the gospel.
This makes even more sense when we look at what was happening in Colossae. These believers were being confronted with teachings that could pull their attention away from the sufficiency of Christ. Later, Colossians 2:8 warns them, “Beware lest anyone cheat you through philosophy and empty deceit,” and Paul also warns them about religious regulations and human teachings (Colossians 2:16–23). Throughout the letter, Paul keeps bringing them back to the same truth: Christ is enough. Stay grounded in Him.
So when Paul says “continue in the faith,” he is not simply saying, “Try harder to behave yourself.” The issue is much deeper. Continue trusting Christ and the gospel you received. Do not allow another teaching, another system, or another hope to move you away from Him.
This is also why this passage should not be turned into works-based salvation. Paul does not say, “Christ reconciled you, but now it is your job to earn the rest of your salvation through good behavior.” He specifically says, “if indeed you continue in the faith.” The issue is faith in Christ, not earning God’s acceptance through human performance.
Continuing in faith does not add anything to the sacrifice of Jesus. Christ’s death is still what reconciles us. Continuing simply means that we keep trusting the One who reconciled us instead of abandoning our faith in Him. We begin by depending upon Christ, and we continue depending upon Christ.
They were alienated from God. Christ reconciled them through His death. His purpose was to present them holy and blameless before God. And Paul tells these reconciled people to continue in the faith, grounded and steadfast, without moving away from the hope of the gospel.
The message is simple: Jesus is the One who reconciles us to God. We cannot reconcile ourselves. But the Christ in whom we first placed our faith is the Christ in whom we are called to continue. Stay grounded in Him, remain steadfast in faith, and do not allow anything to move you away from the hope of the gospel.
2 Timothy 2:11–13
“This is a faithful saying:
For if we died with Him,
We shall also live with Him.
If we endure,
We shall also reign with Him.
If we deny Him,
He also will deny us.
If we are faithless,
He remains faithful;
He cannot deny Himself.”
Paul is suffering for preaching the gospel, and throughout the letter he is encouraging Timothy not to be ashamed of Christ, not to give up when suffering comes, and to remain faithful. Just a few verses before this passage, Paul tells Timothy to “endure hardship as a good soldier of Jesus Christ” (2 Timothy 2:3). Then Paul speaks about his own suffering and imprisonment for the gospel. So when we reach verses 11–13, the subject of endurance and faithfulness to Christ is already right in front of us.
Paul begins by saying, “This is a faithful saying.” What follows appears to be a saying or confession familiar to early Christians. It is written almost like a short poem, with one statement following another. Each statement begins with “if,” and each one describes our relationship with Christ and the consequence connected to it.
Paul first says, “If we died with Him, we shall also live with Him.” The Christian life begins with identifying ourselves with Christ. We die to the old life and receive new life through Him. This fits Paul’s teaching elsewhere about being united with Christ in His death and resurrection. Our hope of life is completely connected to Jesus.
Then Paul says, “If we endure, we shall also reign with Him.” Again, we see the importance of continuing. Paul does not simply talk about beginning with Christ; he talks about enduring with Christ. This makes perfect sense in the context because Timothy is being encouraged to remain faithful even when following Jesus becomes difficult. Endurance means continuing with Christ through hardship, opposition, temptation, suffering, and whatever else may come.
Then comes the strongest warning in the passage: “If we deny Him, He also will deny us.” That is extremely direct. He gives a real warning: if we deny Christ, He will deny us. This also sounds very similar to what Jesus Himself taught. Matthew 10:32–33 says, “Therefore whoever confesses Me before men, him I will also confess before My Father who is in heaven. But whoever denies Me before men, him I will also deny before My Father who is in heaven.” So when Paul says, “If we deny Him, He also will deny us,” he is not introducing some strange new idea. He is repeating a warning that Jesus Himself gave.
Peter denied Jesus three times, yet Peter repented and was restored. So this passage cannot mean that one moment of fear, weakness, or failure automatically places someone beyond restoration. Peter himself proves that denial can be repented of. The warning here is better understood as a settled repudiation of Christ—refusing Him rather than continuing faithfully with Him. That fits the contrast Paul has just given us. On one side is “if we endure.” On the other side is “if we deny Him.” The question is whether we continue with Christ or ultimately repudiate Him.
Then comes the statement that can sometimes cause confusion: “If we are faithless, He remains faithful; He cannot deny Himself.” Some read this as though Paul is saying, “Even if we completely abandon Christ, He will remain faithful to save us anyway.” But we need to read that sentence together with the one immediately before it. Paul has just said, “If we deny Him, He also will deny us.” It would be strange for Paul to immediately turn around and say, “But if you deny Him, don’t worry, He will still save you regardless.”
The key is understanding what it means for Christ to remain faithful. Christ’s faithfulness means that He remains true to who He is and to what He has said. He does not change His character because we become unfaithful. He does not break His word. He remains faithful to His promises, and He also remains faithful to His warnings. That is why Paul adds, “He cannot deny Himself.” Jesus cannot contradict Himself. He cannot say one thing and then become unfaithful to His own word. If He promises life to those who belong to Him, He is faithful. If He promises that those who endure will reign with Him, He is faithful. And if He warns, “If we deny Him, He also will deny us,” He is faithful to that statement too.
Christians are not perfectly faithful every second of their lives. We stumble. We fail. We have weak moments. Peter is a perfect example. He denied Jesus terribly, but his failure was not the end of his story because he returned to Christ and was restored. Our weakness does not make Jesus unfaithful. But that is very different from saying that permanently repudiating Christ carries no consequence. Paul plainly says otherwise. The whole saying therefore holds both promise and warning together. If we died with Him, we will live with Him. If we endure, we will reign with Him. If we deny Him, He will deny us. And even when human beings are unfaithful, Christ remains completely true to Himself.
Once again this passage fits naturally with the passages we have already looked at. John says abide. Hebrews says hold fast and warns against departing. Colossians says continue in the faith. And here Paul says “if we endure” while warning, “if we deny Him, He also will deny us.” Different writers use different words, but we continue seeing the same call to perseverance.
The message is simple: continue with Christ. Endure when following Him becomes difficult. Do not mistake a moment of weakness for permanent rejection, because Christ restores those who turn back to Him. But neither should we make His faithfulness mean that denying Him does not matter. Jesus remains faithful to everything He has said—both His promises and His warnings.
Galatians 5:19-21
'Now the works of the flesh are evident, which are: adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lewdness, idolatry, sorcery, hatred, contentions, jealousies, outbursts of wrath, selfish ambitions, dissensions, heresies, envy, murders, drunkenness, revelries, and the like; of which I tell you beforehand, just as I also told you in time past, that those who practice such things will not inherit the kingdom of God.'
Paul is writing to believers, and beginning in verse 16 he tells them, “Walk in the Spirit, and you shall not fulfill the lust of the flesh.” He then explains that the flesh and the Spirit are opposed to one another. So Paul is describing two very different directions a person can walk in: following the desires of the flesh or walking according to the Spirit.
When Paul uses the word “flesh” here, he is not talking about our physical bodies. The Greek word is sarx, and in this context Paul is talking about our fallen human desires when they operate apart from submission to God. It is that pull toward sin, selfishness, rebellion, and satisfying ourselves rather than following the Spirit. That is why Paul calls the behaviors that come from it “the works of the flesh.”
Paul then gives examples of what those works look like. His list includes sexual sins such as “adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lewdness,” along with “idolatry” and “sorcery.” The Greek word translated sorcery is pharmakeia. It was associated with magical and occult practices and could involve the use of drugs or potions in those practices. Paul’s concern here is participation in occult and magical practices.
Then Paul moves into sins that destroy relationships: “hatred, contentions, jealousies, outbursts of wrath, selfish ambitions, dissensions, heresies, envy,” and even “murders.” He also mentions “drunkenness” and “revelries.” This is important because sometimes Christians look at a list like this and focus only on sexual immorality, drunkenness, or occult practices while overlooking hatred, jealousy, rage, selfish ambition, division, and envy. Paul puts all of them under the works of the flesh.
Then Paul adds “and the like.” In other words, this is not meant to be an exhaustive list of every possible sin. Paul is giving examples of what a life controlled by the flesh can produce. But the strongest part of the passage comes at the end. Paul says, “those who practice such things will not inherit the kingdom of God.”
The word “practice” is important. He is describing people whose lives are characterized by these things—people who continue practicing them as a way of life. The Greek wording carries the sense of doing or practicing these things, and the surrounding contrast between walking by the Spirit and fulfilling the desires of the flesh shows that Paul is concerned with the direction and pattern of a person’s life.
That distinction matters because Christians still struggle with sin. Paul has just acknowledged that “the flesh lusts against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh” (Galatians 5:17). There is a battle. Becoming a Christian does not mean temptation disappears or that we never fail again. The presence of a struggle does not mean someone has been abandoned by God. In fact, fighting against the flesh and responding to the Spirit shows something very different from peacefully surrendering yourself to sin without repentance.
So this passage is not saying, “If you ever become jealous, lose your temper, get drunk, commit sexual sin, or fall into one of these sins, you can never inherit God’s kingdom.” If that were Paul’s meaning, salvation would depend upon sinless perfection. The warning concerns continuing in these things as an unrepentant way of life.
But we should not soften Paul’s warning in the other direction either. He does not say persistent sin is unimportant because someone previously made a confession of faith. He tells a Christian community very plainly that “those who practice such things will not inherit the kingdom of God.” Whatever theological system we bring to the passage, those words need to retain their seriousness.
Paul does not tell believers, “Because you believed at some point in the past, it does not matter which direction you walk now.” He tells them to “walk in the Spirit.” He warns them about the works of the flesh and tells them what the outcome is for those who practice them. Immediately after this warning, Paul gives the opposite picture. Galatians 5:22–23 says, “But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, longsuffering, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control.” On one side are the works of the flesh. On the other is the fruit of the Spirit.
Notice again that Paul calls it fruit. Fruit does not purchase salvation. Fruit grows because there is life. Just as we discussed in John 15, obedience and spiritual fruit are not the price we pay to make God save us. They are what the Spirit begins producing in a life that is surrendered to Christ.
Paul continues in Galatians 5:24 by saying, “And those who are Christ’s have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires.” Then verse 25 says, “If we live in the Spirit, let us also walk in the Spirit.” That is really the heart of the entire section. If our life comes from the Spirit, then our actual walk should increasingly come under the Spirit’s direction.
That does not mean instant perfection. Growth can be messy. Christians can struggle. Christians can fall. Christians can need correction, deliverance, accountability, and repentance. The question is not whether someone has ever committed one of the sins on Paul’s list. The question is whether they are surrendering themselves to the flesh as their settled way of life or continuing to turn toward Christ and allowing the Spirit to change them.
This also helps us avoid two opposite errors. On one side is works-based salvation, where someone believes they must behave perfectly enough to earn eternal life. Paul is not teaching that. But on the other side is the idea that because salvation is by grace, persistent and unrepentant sin can never have any serious spiritual consequence. Paul does not teach that either. Grace does not mean sin no longer matters. The same Paul who taught justification by faith also warned believers that “those who practice such things will not inherit the kingdom of God.” We need to allow both truths to stand.
Sometimes Scripture warns about denying Christ. Sometimes it warns about departing from the faith. Here Paul warns about surrendering ourselves to a life controlled by the flesh rather than continuing to walk by the Spirit.
The message is simple: we are saved by grace, not by perfect behavior, but grace does not give us permission to make peace with sin. There is a difference between struggling with the flesh and surrendering to it. Believers are called to walk by the Spirit, repent when we fall, allow Him to transform us, and never treat persistent, unrepentant sin as though it has no consequence.
Romans 11:20–22
“Well said. Because of unbelief they were broken off, and you stand by faith. Do not be haughty, but fear. For if God did not spare the natural branches, He may not spare you either. Therefore consider the goodness and severity of God: on those who fell, severity; but toward you, goodness, if you continue in His goodness. Otherwise you also will be cut off.”
Romans 9-11, these chapters deal heavily with Israel, the Gentiles, God’s promises, faith, and unbelief. Paul is explaining how many within Israel rejected Christ while Gentiles were coming to faith in Him. By Romans 11, Paul uses the picture of an olive tree to help explain what has happened. Paul describes some of the natural branches as being broken off and wild olive branches being grafted in among the others. The natural branches represent unbelieving Israelites, while the wild branches picture Gentiles being brought in. So the immediate discussion is bigger than one individual Christian’s salvation. Paul is talking about Israel and the Gentiles and their relationship to God’s covenant blessings.
But what caused the branches to be broken off? Paul tells us plainly: “Because of unbelief they were broken off.” That is incredibly important. Paul does not say God randomly decided He no longer wanted them. The issue is unbelief. They refused faith in Christ. Then Paul turns to the Gentile and says, “and you stand by faith.” Again, the contrast is very simple: they were broken off because of unbelief; you stand by faith. The Gentiles were not grafted in because they were better than Israel. They did not earn their place. They had absolutely nothing to brag about. Their standing was by faith. That is why Paul immediately says, “Do not be haughty, but fear.” Paul is warning Gentile believers against becoming arrogant toward unbelieving Israel. They could easily begin thinking, “God rejected them and chose us because there is something better about us.” Paul destroys that attitude immediately. He reminds them that they did not support the root; the root supports them (Romans 11:18). They are standing by faith, not by superiority.
Then Paul gives the reason they should take the warning seriously: “For if God did not spare the natural branches, He may not spare you either.” That is a real warning. Paul does not tell them, “Israel was broken off because of unbelief, but once you have been grafted in, unbelief could never have any consequence for you.” He does the opposite. He points directly to what happened to the natural branches and tells the Gentile believers not to become arrogant, but to fear. Then Paul says, “Therefore consider the goodness and severity of God.” Both matter. God’s goodness is real, but so is His severity. Paul says there was severity “on those who fell,” while toward the Gentiles there is God’s goodness.
But then comes the condition: “If you continue in His goodness.” And immediately after that: “Otherwise you also will be cut off.” The word “continue” is important because, once again, we are dealing with perseverance. Paul is speaking to those who presently “stand by faith,” and he tells them they must continue. He does not tell people who are completely outside the tree that they might someday be cut off from it. He speaks to those pictured as presently grafted in and warns them against the same unbelief that resulted in other branches being removed.
This is why Romans 11 fits so well with the other passages we have been looking at. John says abide. Hebrews says hold fast and warns about departing. Colossians says continue in the faith. Here Paul says “you stand by faith” and warns, “if you continue…otherwise you also will be cut off.”
There is also something extremely important immediately after our passage that helps us understand Paul’s point. Romans 11:23 says concerning the branches that were broken off, “And they also, if they do not continue in unbelief, will be grafted in, for God is able to graft them in again.” Notice the language: “again.” The broken branches are not presented as hopeless. Their problem is unbelief, but Paul says if they do not continue in unbelief, God is able to graft them in again. That makes the role of faith and unbelief very clear throughout the illustration. Unbelief leads to being broken off. Faith is how the Gentile stands. Continuing matters. And those who were broken off can be grafted in again if they turn from unbelief. This is also important because Romans 11 should not be used to teach that God permanently rejected Israel and replaced Israel with Gentiles. Paul specifically rejects that idea. Romans 11:1 begins with the question, “Has God cast away His people?” and Paul answers, “Certainly not!” Later he specifically speaks about the possibility of those natural branches being grafted in again.
So Paul’s olive-tree illustration contains both warning and hope. Gentiles have no reason to boast because they stand by faith. Israel is not beyond restoration because unbelieving branches can be grafted in again through faith. The dividing issue throughout the passage is faith versus unbelief.
Those who are pictured as standing by faith and grafted into the tree are explicitly warned that they must continue, otherwise they too can be cut off. That fits the larger argument against unconditional eternal security. Paul does not teach the Gentile believer to presume upon a past position while abandoning faith. In fact, he warns against exactly that kind of arrogance. Their present standing is by faith, and they are warned to continue rather than fall into unbelief.
The message is simple: do not boast about where you stand. You stand by faith. The natural branches were broken off because of unbelief, so do not assume unbelief could never matter for you. Continue in God’s goodness and continue in faith. And remember that even those who have been broken off are not beyond restoration—if they do not continue in unbelief, God is able to graft them in again.
1 Corinthians 9:27
'But I discipline my body and bring it into subjection, lest, when I have preached to others, I myself should become disqualified.'
Beginning in 1 Corinthians 9:24, Paul compares the Christian life to running a race. He says, “Do you not know that those who run in a race all run, but one receives the prize? Run in such a way that you may obtain it.” He then explains that athletes exercise self-control because they are trying to win a prize. The difference is that earthly athletes compete for something temporary, while believers are running for something eternal. Paul says they compete for “a perishable crown, but we for an imperishable crown.” His point is that the Christian life is not something we begin and then become careless about. It is pictured as a race that we are actually supposed to run with purpose and finish faithfully.
In 1 Corinthians 9:26 he says, “Therefore I run thus: not with uncertainty. Thus I fight: not as one who beats the air.” Paul knows where he is going and what he is living for. He is not wandering around without direction. That leads directly into verse 27, where he says, “But I discipline my body and bring it into subjection.” Paul is talking about self-control. He refuses to allow his desires and appetites to become his master. His point is that his desires have to remain under submission to Christ rather than being allowed to control the direction of his life.
What makes this especially important is who is saying it. This is Paul. He had encountered the risen Jesus. He had preached the gospel, planted churches, suffered for Christ, received revelation, and been used powerfully by God. Yet Paul does not look back at everything he had experienced and say, “Because I was saved years ago and God has used me in ministry, what I do from this point forward cannot possibly matter.” Instead, he continues to take his own walk with Christ seriously. He says he disciplines himself “lest, when I have preached to others, I myself should become disqualified.”
The word translated “disqualified” is the Greek word adokimos. It is the idea of failing a test, being rejected, or not being approved. To be careful here… the word itself does not automatically mean “lose salvation” every time it appears. Let’s simply look at the context. Paul has just told believers to “run in such a way that you may obtain” the prize. He talks about an imperishable crown, exercising self-control, running with purpose, and then avoiding disqualification. Whatever someone believes the exact nature of that disqualification is, Paul clearly does not speak as though beginning the race makes finishing it irrelevant.
There is also something very important in Paul’s statement “when I have preached to others.” Paul understands that being used by God to minister to other people does not mean his own walk with Christ no longer matters. Someone can preach to others, teach Scripture, minister, lead, and help other people while still needing to guard their own heart and life. Ministry success is not a substitute for personal faithfulness. Preaching Scripture to someone else does not remove our responsibility to live according to the truth we preach.
The placement of this passage also matters because Paul’s thought does not actually stop at the end of chapter 9. The chapter divisions were added later. Immediately after Paul says he does not want to become “disqualified,” he begins talking about Israel in the wilderness in 1 Corinthians 10. Paul reminds the Corinthians that Israel experienced incredible spiritual privileges. They passed through the sea, experienced God’s supernatural provision, and drank from the spiritual Rock, which Paul identifies with Christ. Yet many of them later fell through idolatry, sexual immorality, testing God, and rebellion. Paul specifically tells the Corinthian believers that Israel’s experiences were recorded as examples and warnings for them.
That connection is important. Paul first talks about running the race, obtaining the prize, exercising self-control, and avoiding disqualification, and then immediately gives Israel as an example of people who experienced tremendous spiritual privilege but did not continue faithfully. That entire discussion eventually leads to Paul’s warning in 1 Corinthians 10:12: “Therefore let him who thinks he stands take heed lest he fall.” In other words, Paul is warning against spiritual presumption. Past experiences with God should never make us think continued faithfulness no longer matters.
At the same time, Paul is not teaching works-based salvation. He is not saying that he can earn eternal life by disciplining himself hard enough. Jesus is still the Savior. Grace is still grace. Self-control does not replace the finished work of Christ. But Paul also does not use grace as an excuse for spiritual carelessness. He understands that following Christ involves resisting sinful desires, exercising self-control, remaining faithful, and continuing to run the race.
We also need to distinguish perseverance from perfection. Paul is not teaching that a Christian must run the race without ever stumbling. Christians can stumble. They can become tired. They can struggle. They can need correction and encouragement. They can sin and repent. The issue is not whether the runner ever stumbles; the issue is whether the runner continues running. There is a major difference between falling during the race and abandoning the race altogether.
This is why 1 Corinthians 9:27 fits so well with the overall message we have been seeing throughout Scripture. John gives us the picture of remaining in the vine. Hebrews tells believers to hold fast. Colossians tells reconciled believers to continue in the faith. Paul now gives us another picture: run the race with the intention of finishing it. These illustrations are different, but they all push against the idea that a past beginning makes continued faithfulness meaningless.
Paul himself does not speak as though his conversion, apostleship, ministry, or spiritual experiences gave him an unconditional security that made his future response to Christ irrelevant. Instead, he remains watchful over his own life. If Paul believed he needed to continue running faithfully after preaching to others, we should not treat perseverance as unnecessary simply because we can point to something that happened in our past.
The message is simple: starting the race does not mean we no longer need to run. Being used by God does not mean our own walk with Him no longer matters. We do not earn salvation through discipline, but neither should grace produce carelessness. Keep your life submitted to Christ, keep running toward the imperishable prize, and take seriously Paul’s own warning that after preaching to others, he did not want to become disqualified.
1 Corinthians 10:1–12
“Moreover, brethren, I do not want you to be unaware that all our fathers were under the cloud, all passed through the sea, all were baptized into Moses… all ate the same spiritual food, and all drank the same spiritual drink… But with most of them God was not well pleased, for their bodies were scattered in the wilderness… Now these things became our examples… Therefore let him who thinks he stands take heed lest he fall.”
Paul begins this section by saying, “Moreover, brethren.” He is writing to the Christian church in Corinth. He is not simply telling unbelievers what happened to Israel hundreds of years earlier. He takes Israel’s story and deliberately uses it as a warning for believers. Paul reminds them about the generation of Israelites whom God delivered from Egypt. They had experienced incredible things. Paul repeatedly uses the word “all.” They were all under the cloud, they all passed through the sea, they were all baptized into Moses, they all ate the same spiritual food, and they all drank the same spiritual drink. Paul even says, “they drank of that spiritual Rock that followed them, and that Rock was Christ.”
These people had witnessed God’s power firsthand. They had watched God deliver them from Egypt. They walked through the Red Sea. They experienced God’s guidance and supernatural provision. They were not people who had never encountered God or knew nothing about Him. They experienced tremendous covenant privilege and God’s intervention in their lives. But then Paul says something sobering in verse 5: “But with most of them God was not well pleased, for their bodies were scattered in the wilderness.”
That is the contrast Paul wants the Corinthians to see. They all experienced these incredible things, but not all of them finished faithfully. Experiencing God’s power did not give Israel permission to later live however they wanted. Their previous experiences did not make their later rebellion meaningless. Paul then tells us exactly why he is bringing this up. First Corinthians 10:6 says, “Now these things became our examples, to the intent that we should not lust after evil things as they also lusted.”
Notice the words “our examples.” Paul is not simply giving the Corinthians a history lesson. He is saying, in effect, look at what happened to them and learn from it. Do not repeat what they did. He then walks through some of Israel’s failures. He warns the Corinthians, “do not become idolaters” (verse 7). Then, “nor let us commit sexual immorality” (verse 8). Then, “nor let us tempt Christ” (verse 9). Then, “nor complain” as some of them did (verse 10). This matters because Paul does not talk as though believers are automatically incapable of these things. He warns Christians not to do them. The entire purpose of using Israel as the example is to tell the Corinthian church that spiritual privilege should never produce spiritual arrogance.
Then Paul repeats his point in verse 11: “Now all these things happened to them as examples, and they were written for our admonition.” That is about as clear as Paul could make it. These events were written down as warnings for God’s people who came afterward. Israel’s failures were supposed to teach Christians something about the danger of sin, idolatry, rebellion, and presumption. This is especially important when we consider the problems already happening in Corinth. This church was dealing with division, sexual immorality, lawsuits among believers, arguments about Christian freedom, and questions involving food connected with idolatry. In the chapters surrounding this passage, Paul is particularly concerned about idolatry and how the Corinthians use their freedom. So Israel’s story becomes a very relevant warning: do not think spiritual privilege means you can play with sin and remain untouched by its consequences.
That brings us to Paul’s conclusion in verse 12: “Therefore let him who thinks he stands take heed lest he fall.” The word “therefore” connects the warning directly to everything Paul has just explained. Israel experienced God’s deliverance and provision, yet many fell in the wilderness. Therefore, the person who thinks he stands should take heed. In simple terms: do not become spiritually overconfident. Paul does not say, “Because you stand, there is absolutely no reason to be concerned about falling.” He says the opposite: “Let him who thinks he stands take heed lest he fall.” The warning calls for humility, watchfulness, and continued dependence upon God.
They experienced tremendous spiritual privilege and nevertheless came under God’s judgment when they turned toward idolatry, immorality, and rebellion. We can simply allow him to make his own application: their story was written for our warning, so if you think you stand, take heed lest you fall.
This also fits with something Paul said immediately before this chapter. At the end of 1 Corinthians 9, Paul uses the picture of an athlete running a race. He talks about disciplining himself so that after preaching to others he would not become “disqualified” (1 Corinthians 9:27). Then chapter 10 begins with Israel. That chapter break was added later; Paul’s thought continues. He has just talked about running faithfully and avoiding disqualification, and then he gives Israel as a powerful example of people who began with tremendous privilege but did not finish well.
And Paul does not leave believers without hope. Immediately after saying, “take heed lest he fall,” verse 13 says, “No temptation has overtaken you except such as is common to man; but God is faithful.” God provides a way of escape so that believers can endure temptation. Paul’s answer is not, “You are helpless, so you are probably going to fall.” His answer is that God is faithful, so do not presume upon sin, depend upon Him when temptation comes.
Then in verse 14 Paul gives the practical response: “Therefore, my beloved, flee from idolatry.” Notice again how he addresses them: “my beloved.” These warnings are being given to people Paul loves as fellow believers. His goal is to keep them from becoming careless with sin because they assume their spiritual experiences make them untouchable.
This is an important passage when discussing Once Saved, Always Saved because Paul does not encourage believers to look backward at a past spiritual experience and assume that what happens afterward cannot matter. Israel had experiences. Israel had deliverance. Israel had supernatural provision. Yet Paul still uses their failure as a warning to Christians who presently think they stand.
First Corinthians 10 therefore adds another important piece to the overall picture. Spiritual privilege does not remove the need for perseverance. Past experiences with God do not give us permission to become careless in the present. Israel’s history was deliberately recorded as a warning for believers so that we would not repeat their rebellion.
The message is simple: do not presume upon where you stand today. Learn from those who came before you. Take sin seriously, flee idolatry, depend upon God’s faithfulness when temptation comes, and continue walking with Christ. As Paul himself says, “let him who thinks he stands take heed lest he fall.”
Matthew 18:21–35 — The Unforgiving Servant
Matthew 18:21–22 begins when Peter asks Jesus how many times he should forgive someone who sins against him. Peter asks whether forgiving someone seven times would be enough, and Jesus responds that forgiveness must go far beyond that. Jesus then tells the parable of the unforgiving servant to explain why people who have received mercy from God must also extend mercy to others.
In the parable, a king begins settling accounts with his servants. One servant owes him an enormous debt; so large that he has absolutely no ability to repay it. When the servant realizes what is about to happen, he falls before his master and begs for patience. Then something incredible happens. Matthew 18:27 says the master was “moved with compassion, released him, and forgave him the debt.” The servant did not work off the debt. He did not earn his freedom. The master forgave it. The debt was actually canceled because the master showed him mercy.
Jesus does not say the servant just thought he had been forgiven. He does not say forgiveness was offered but never received. Within the story, the master forgave the debt. The servant walked away having received mercy that he could never have earned for himself.
But then the forgiven servant encounters another servant who owes him a much smaller debt. Instead of remembering the enormous mercy he had just received, he grabs the man and demands payment. The fellow servant falls down and begs him for patience using language very similar to what the first servant had just used before the king. But this time there is no mercy. The forgiven servant refuses to forgive and has the man thrown into prison.
When the king hears what happened, he is furious. He calls the first man back and says in Matthew 18:32–33, “You wicked servant! I forgave you all that debt because you begged me. Should you not also have had compassion on your fellow servant, just as I had pity on you?” Notice what the master himself says: “I forgave you all that debt.”
That is significant when discussing the idea that this man never actually received forgiveness. Within Jesus’ own story, the master plainly says that the debt had been forgiven. The problem is not that the servant never received mercy. The problem is that after receiving tremendous mercy, he refused to extend mercy to someone else.
Then something very serious happens. Matthew 18:34 says the master becomes angry and “delivered him to the torturers until he should pay all that was due to him.” The servant who had previously been released from an unpayable debt now finds himself under judgment because of his hard and unforgiving heart.
But the most important part comes after the parable because Jesus tells us how He wants His disciples to apply it. Matthew 18:35 says, “So My heavenly Father also will do to you if each of you, from his heart, does not forgive his brother his trespasses.”
Jesus does not leave this as an interesting story about an imaginary king. He applies the warning directly to His followers. The entire parable began with Peter asking Jesus about forgiveness, and Jesus ends by warning His disciples about refusing to forgive from the heart.
Grace received is supposed to produce grace toward others. Someone who understands how much God has forgiven should not turn around and stubbornly refuse mercy to everyone else. Jesus treats a hardened, settled refusal to forgive as spiritually serious.
This passage is especially difficult to fit with a version of Once Saved, Always Saved that says nothing occurring after someone receives forgiveness can have any bearing on their final accountability before God. Jesus deliberately tells a story about a servant whose debt was genuinely forgiven and then gives a serious warning based upon what that servant subsequently does.
Jesus does not treat previously received mercy as permission for continued, hardened disobedience without consequence. Salvation is by grace. Forgiveness cannot be earned. But the grace we receive is supposed to transform how we live. Jesus repeatedly calls His followers to continue with Him, obey Him, forgive as they have been forgiven, and take seriously the consequences of hardening themselves against His commands.
The message is simple: we do not forgive others so that we can earn God’s grace. We forgive because we have received God’s grace. But Jesus gives a very serious warning against receiving mercy while stubbornly refusing to extend mercy. Grace is freely given, but it was never meant to leave our hearts unchanged.
Ezekiel 18:24 — A Pattern of God’s Moral Government
“But when a righteous man turns away from his righteousness and commits iniquity, and does according to all the abominations that the wicked man does, shall he live? All the righteousness which he has done shall not be remembered; because of the unfaithfulness of which he is guilty and the sin which he has committed, because of them he shall die.”
Ezekiel 18 was written to Israel under the Old Covenant, and the chapter is addressing personal responsibility before God, righteousness, wickedness, repentance, and judgment. We should not take one Old Testament verse and pretend Ezekiel was directly answering a modern theological debate about Once Saved, Always Saved. He was not.
However, Ezekiel 18 reveals an important biblical pattern concerning turning toward God and turning away from Him, and that pattern helps us understand why the warnings we have already examined in the New Testament should be taken seriously.
The people of Israel had been using a proverb that said, “The fathers have eaten sour grapes, and the children’s teeth are set on edge” (Ezekiel 18:2). In simple terms, they were blaming their present condition on previous generations. God responds by emphasizing individual responsibility. A son is not automatically condemned because his father was wicked, and a wicked person is not protected simply because someone before him was righteous. Each person is accountable before God for his own response to Him.
That is why Ezekiel 18 repeatedly presents the possibility of change in both directions. A wicked person can turn from wickedness and live, while a righteous person can turn away from righteousness and face judgment. Ezekiel 18:21 says, “But if a wicked man turns from all his sins which he has committed, keeps all My statutes, and does what is lawful and right, he shall surely live; he shall not die.” God is willing to receive the person who turns away from wickedness.
Then verse 24 gives the opposite possibility: “But when a righteous man turns away from his righteousness and commits iniquity… shall he live?” The answer is no. God says the righteousness he previously practiced will not protect him while he deliberately turns himself toward wickedness. The important principle is that past faithfulness is not presented as permission for future rebellion.
Again, under the Old Covenant, the language of “live” and “die” can involve physical life, covenant judgment, and Israel’s historical situation. Therefore, I would not use Ezekiel 18:24 solely by itself and say, “This verse directly proves that a New Covenant Christian can lose eternal salvation.” That goes beyond what Ezekiel is specifically addressing. But as a supporting passage, to this overall teaching, it reveals something consistent about God’s dealings with people: God takes both repentance and turning away seriously.
And the chapter makes God’s heart beautifully clear. Ezekiel 18:23 says, “Do I have any pleasure at all that the wicked should die… and not that he should turn from his ways and live?” Then verse 32 says, “For I have no pleasure in the death of one who dies… Therefore turn and live!”
God is not looking for reasons to destroy people. He calls people to turn and live. The wicked person is not locked forever into his previous wickedness if he repents, and the righteous person is warned not to presume upon yesterday’s righteousness while turning toward rebellion today.
That is why Ezekiel 18 works well at the end of this teaching; not as the main proof against Once Saved, Always Saved, but as part of the broader biblical pattern we have already established much more directly from the New Testament.
The New Testament passages have told believers to abide, continue, endure, hold fast, stand by faith, take heed lest they fall, and not depart from the living God. Ezekiel shows that this concern about turning toward God versus turning away from Him did not suddenly appear in the New Testament. Scripture consistently treats our response to God as meaningful.
This also helps prevent a misunderstanding of perseverance. Perseverance does not mean earning salvation by accumulating enough righteous deeds. Ezekiel is not teaching that someone builds up a bank account of good works that purchases eternal life. In fact, the chapter emphasizes repentance and the direction in which someone turns. The issue is whether someone turns toward God or away from Him.
That distinction fits everything we have been saying. A Christian can stumble and repent. A believer can struggle and turn back toward Christ. The gospel is filled with grace for the repentant. What Scripture repeatedly warns against is settled rebellion, hardened unbelief, apostasy, and deliberately turning away from God while presuming that a previous experience makes our present response irrelevant.
The message is simple: God desires repentance and life. He calls the wicked to turn from wickedness, and He warns the righteous not to turn away. Our hope is never in having behaved well enough in the past. Our hope is in God, and His call remains: turn toward Him, remain faithful to Him, and live.
Lukewarm
From the very beginning, Satan’s deception has been the same: convince people that they can disobey God and still be secure. In the Garden, God had already spoken clearly about the consequence of rebellion, yet the serpent came behind Him and said, “You will not surely die” (Genesis 3:4). In other words, God said there would be consequences, but the serpent told them there wouldn’t be. That lie is still dangerous today. Whenever we begin believing that we can knowingly reject God’s authority, settle comfortably into rebellion, refuse repentance, and somehow our relationship with Him can never be affected, we need to recognize how contrary that thinking is to the warnings throughout Scripture.
Grace is there for the repentant. But grace was never given so we could comfortably remain in rebellion while telling ourselves that a decision we made years ago makes our present relationship with Christ irrelevant.
Jesus is not only Savior; He is Lord. We love talking about Jesus saving us, rescuing us, forgiving us, healing us, and giving us eternal life… and we should. But the same Jesus who saves us also says, “Why do you call Me ‘Lord, Lord,’ and not do the things which I say?” (Luke 6:46). Lordship means authority. If Jesus is Lord, then He has the right to tell me how to live. Christianity is not adding Jesus to a life that I remain completely in charge of. Following Jesus means surrendering the throne.
That does not mean obedience earns salvation. We obey because He is our Lord, not because obedience makes us our own savior. But there is something deeply wrong with wanting Jesus’ blood while rejecting Jesus’ authority, wanting forgiveness without repentance, wanting heaven without holiness, wanting a Savior we never intend to follow. The gospel is not, “Say the right thing once and then live in complete rebellion without concern.” Jesus said, “If anyone desires to come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow Me” (Matthew 16:24).
This is where the fear of the Lord matters. It is recognizing who He is. He is holy. He is righteous. He is Judge. He is King. He is worthy of obedience. Psalm 19:9 says, “The fear of the Lord is clean, enduring forever.” Proverbs 8:13 says, “The fear of the Lord is to hate evil.” A genuine fear of God does not make sin impossible, but it makes it impossible to become completely comfortable calling evil good simply because we want to keep doing it.
We cannot create a version of God who only comforts us and never confronts us. The God who is merciful is also holy. The God who forgives also commands repentance. The Jesus who welcomed sinners also told them to leave their life of sin. Grace and holiness are not enemies. Grace does not lower God’s standard until rebellion becomes acceptable. Grace brings us to God, forgives us, empowers us, teaches us, corrects us, and transforms us.
That brings us to Jesus’ warning to the church in Laodicea. Revelation 3:15–16 says, “I know your works, that you are neither cold nor hot. I could wish you were cold or hot. So then, because you are lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will vomit you out of My mouth.”
Notice who Jesus is speaking to: a church. And notice how He begins: “I know your works.”
Jesus sees past religious appearance. He sees past the church attendance, Christian vocabulary, social-media Bible verses, worship music, ministry titles, and public professions. He knows what is actually happening underneath all of it. We can convince other people that we are walking closely with God. We can even convince ourselves. We cannot convince Christ.
The Laodiceans had become spiritually comfortable and self-satisfied. Revelation 3:17 says they were saying, “I am rich, have become wealthy, and have need of nothing.” But Jesus tells them they did not understand their true spiritual condition. They thought they were doing fine while Christ saw something completely different. That may be one of the most frightening conditions a person can reach: believing you are spiritually healthy while Jesus is telling you that you need to repent.
That is what makes lukewarmness so dangerous. Lukewarm Christianity wants enough Jesus to feel saved but not enough Jesus to surrender. It wants Christianity without crucifying the flesh. It wants God’s promises without God’s commands. It wants grace without repentance, blessing without obedience, heaven without holiness, and Jesus as Savior while resisting Jesus as Lord.
- It says, “I believe in God,” while living as though God has no authority over anything.
- It says, “Jesus knows my heart,” while refusing to allow Jesus to change that heart.
- It says, “Nobody is perfect,” not as a humble confession of dependence upon grace, but as an excuse to remain exactly where conviction has been telling us to change.
- It says, “God loves me,” as though God’s love means God will never confront, discipline, correct, or call us out of sin.
That is not grace. That is presumption.
Lukewarmness is not simply having a bad week spiritually. Lukewarmness is deeper than emotion. It is a heart that has become comfortable with divided allegiance and no longer sees its condition clearly. And Jesus does not congratulate that condition. He confronts it. Revelation 3:19 says, “As many as I love, I rebuke and chasten. Therefore be zealous and repent.” There is the heart of Jesus even in this severe warning: repent.
Jesus’ rebuke is not proof that He does not love them. He specifically says He rebukes and disciplines because He loves them. He exposes their condition because He is calling them out of it. His warning is severe because the condition is serious, but His command to repent shows that restoration is still being offered.
Jesus says, Wake up. See your condition. Stop pretending everything is fine. Repent. Become zealous. Return to Me.
And then comes Revelation 3:20: “Behold, I stand at the door and knock.” This verse is often used as an evangelistic invitation to unbelievers, but in exact context Jesus is speaking to the church at Laodicea. Christ is standing at the door calling people who claim His name to open the door and fellowship with Him. That should shake us. It is possible to have the appearance of church while Christ is calling people inside that church back into genuine fellowship with Himself.
What we consistently produce reveals what we are actually following. James 2:17 says, “Faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead.” Jesus repeatedly taught that trees are recognized by their fruit. Our lives will never display perfect fruit, but genuine relationship with Christ should produce something. There should be conviction, repentance, growth, surrender, love, obedience, and increasing transformation.
Lukewarm Faith
Lukewarm faith is profession without surrender. It knows Christian language but resists Christian obedience. It wants to be identified with Jesus without actually allowing Jesus to govern the life. It believes enough to claim the benefits of Christianity while remaining unwilling to let Christ confront its desires, relationships, habits, priorities, attitudes, entertainment, money, sexuality, bitterness, pride, unforgiveness, or secret sin.
Lukewarm faith says, “Jesus is Lord,” but then creates a list of areas where Jesus is not allowed to be Lord. It obeys when obedience is convenient and negotiates when obedience becomes costly. It follows Scripture until Scripture contradicts something it desperately wants. Then instead of allowing the Word to correct the life, it begins looking for ways to reinterpret the Word so the life does not have to change.
Lukewarm faith can sit in church every week and still be lukewarm. It can know Scripture. It can worship loudly. It can serve in ministry. It can post Christian content. External Christianity is not the same thing as surrendered Christianity. Jesus’ words to Laodicea remind us that Christ sees beyond the outward appearance and knows the actual condition of the heart.
Lukewarm faith also loves the phrase “God knows my heart” while forgetting that this is exactly why we should take our spiritual condition seriously. Yes, God knows your heart. He knows whether you are struggling against sin or protecting it. He knows whether you are weak and crying out for help or deliberately refusing repentance. He knows whether you genuinely want freedom or simply want reassurance that you can remain where you are.
There is a difference between struggling with sin and defending sin. There is a difference between falling and deciding to stay down. There is a difference between saying, “Lord, help me overcome this,” and saying, “Lord, I have already decided I am keeping this, so please stop convicting me about it.” The first recognizes Christ’s lordship even in weakness. The second begins placing our desires above His authority.
True faith does not mean instant perfection. It means Christ has become the direction of the life. When we fall, we turn toward Him. When He corrects us, we listen. When His Word exposes something, we do not rewrite Scripture to protect ourselves. When the Holy Spirit convicts us, we repent. When obedience costs something, we remember that Jesus is worth more than whatever He is asking us to surrender.
That is why the answer to lukewarmness is not simply “try harder.” Jesus Himself gives the answer: “Be zealous and repent.” Turn around. Stop defending what God is confronting. Stop trying to keep one hand on Christ and the other wrapped around whatever He is telling you to release. Stop using grace as permission to remain unchanged.
You cannot faithfully follow two opposing kingdoms. You cannot call Jesus Lord while intentionally building a life around refusing His lordship. You cannot turn grace into permission for rebellion and then call that freedom. Grace did not rescue us so we could comfortably return to the chains Christ broke.
The call of Jesus is not to pretend we never struggle. The call is to follow Him in the middle of the struggle. Repent when you fall. Get back up. Keep walking. Keep abiding. Keep believing. Keep surrendering. Keep allowing Him to transform what does not look like Him. Because this entire teaching has never been about whether Christians can stumble. It is about whether Scripture teaches that we can ultimately stop following Christ, settle into unbelief and rebellion, reject His lordship, refuse repentance—and still tell ourselves that none of it can possibly matter because of something that happened in our past. The warnings we have walked through do not allow us to become that comfortable. Jesus said abide. Paul said continue. Hebrews said hold fast. Scripture says endure. And to the lukewarm church, Jesus said repent.
So repent where repentance is needed. Surrender what needs surrendered. Stop making peace with what Jesus died to free you from. Do not settle for carrying the name of Christ while resisting the rule of Christ. He is Savior. He is Lord. Follow Him.
Blessings or Curses
From the beginning, God has presented humanity with clear choices. In the Garden of Eden, there was one command: obey or disobey. The outcome was not symbolic; it was life or death. In the days of Noah, there were only two locations when the flood came: inside the ark or outside of it. There was no middle ground floating safely between judgment and salvation. When it comes to the blood of Jesus, it is either sufficient payment for sin or it is rejected. Scripture consistently presents truth in decisive terms.
The first attempt to blur what God made clear occurred in the Garden. The serpent began with a question: “Has God surely said…?” With that subtle distortion, black-and-white truth began to be smudged into gray. Satan did not openly deny God at first; he questioned, reframed, and misrepresented. That pattern continues today. Confusion often begins by softening what God has spoken plainly. Yet God does not dilute His Word. There is no hidden clause beneath the covenant, no fine print at the bottom of the gospel. While our culture operates in moral ambiguity, the authority of God’s kingdom does not bend to it. His truth does not shift with preference or opinion.
Jesus stands as the bridge between judgment and mercy. He hung in the middle so that we would not have to remain separated from God. His sacrifice does not create a gray area; it creates a way. The cross confronts us with decision. Our choices are not merely right or wrong in a superficial sense. They are life or death, blessing or curse. Scripture repeatedly frames obedience as life and rebellion as destruction.
Joshua confronted Israel with this reality. The people attempted divided loyalty, blending devotion to the Lord with attachment to other gods. Joshua’s response was not tolerant neutrality. He drew a line: “Choose this day whom you will serve… But as for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.” There was no allowance for partial allegiance. Covenant demands clarity. You cannot stand permanently between two masters.
The New Testament echoes this same call to perseverance. In Revelation, those who “conquer” are promised that their names will not be blotted out of the Book of Life. The Greek word nikōn, translated “overcomes” or “conquers,” describes those who remain faithful to Christ despite pressure, temptation, and complacency. Conquering is not sinless perfection; it is steadfast endurance. It is perseverance in faith and obedience until the end.
God’s pattern has never changed. There are blessings for obedience and consequences for rebellion. The call is not to fear-driven legalism but to wholehearted allegiance. The gospel invites us into grace, but grace calls us to remain. The line is clear. The choice is real. Life and death are set before us.
But What About the Verses Used for Once Saved, Always Saved?
Now, if you believe in Once Saved, Always Saved, you have probably been foaming at the mouth through this teaching waiting for me to get to certain Scriptures. I already know some of the verses that may immediately come to mind. “No one can snatch me out of His hand!” “Nothing can separate us from the love of God!” “We are sealed with the Holy Spirit!” “Jesus said He would lose none of those the Father gave Him!”
And you know what? Those verses are in the Bible too, and we need to deal with them.
I do not want to build a belief by collecting only the Scriptures that support what I already believe while ignoring everything that appears to challenge it. If I expect someone who believes in Once Saved, Always Saved to seriously consider Hebrews 6, Hebrews 10, John 15, Colossians 1, Romans 11, and the other passages we have studied, then I also need to seriously consider the passages they believe teach eternal security.
Before we look at them, though, we need to understand the actual disagreement. I believe believers are secure in Christ. I believe God is faithful. I believe Jesus keeps His sheep. I believe the Holy Spirit seals believers. I believe Satan cannot steal our salvation. I believe no demon, person, persecution, hardship, or spiritual power is stronger than Jesus. I believe salvation is by grace through faith and not something we earn by behaving perfectly.
My disagreement with Once Saved, Always Saved is not over whether Jesus is capable of keeping us. Of course He is. The question is whether Scripture teaches that a person who has genuinely come to Christ can later completely abandon faith in Him, reject Him, persist in unbelief, and turn away; and still remain eternally saved because they were saved at some point in the past. That is the question we need to keep in mind as we look at these verses.
John 10:27–29 — No One Can Snatch Them From His Hand
John 10:27–29 says, “My sheep hear My voice, and I know them, and they follow Me. And I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; neither shall anyone snatch them out of My hand.”
This is probably one of the most common Scriptures used to support Once Saved, Always Saved. The argument is simple: Jesus says His sheep will never perish and nobody can snatch them out of His hand. Therefore, once someone is saved, they can never be lost.
I absolutely believe Jesus’ promise here. Nobody can overpower Jesus and steal one of His sheep from Him. Satan cannot reach into the hand of Christ and take you. Another person cannot take you. Persecution cannot take you. Demonic powers cannot defeat Jesus and remove you from His care. There is tremendous security in what Jesus is saying. Our Shepherd is stronger than anything that could come against us.
But we need to pay attention to exactly what Jesus says. He begins, “My sheep hear My voice, and I know them, and they follow Me.” The sheep Jesus is describing are hearing and following their Shepherd. Then He promises that they will never perish and that no one will snatch them out of His hand.
Being snatched away and choosing to depart are not the same thing. The picture Jesus gives is not of a Shepherd who is too weak to protect His sheep. Quite the opposite. His point is that no outside power can forcibly take His sheep away from Him. The security of the Shepherd is absolute.
But the warning passages we have studied are not describing Satan overpowering Jesus and stealing Christians out of His hand. They warn about unbelief, falling away, denying Christ, departing from the living God, refusing to abide, becoming hardened through sin, and abandoning the faith.
No one has to snatch anything away if a person willfully chooses not to remain. I think of the biblical picture of taking refuge under God’s wings. Psalm 91 describes the person who dwells in the shelter of the Most High and takes refuge under His wings. The shelter is secure. God’s wings are not weak. The safety of the refuge is not the issue. Remaining in the refuge is.
Jesus actually uses similar imagery in Matthew 23:37 when He laments over Jerusalem, saying that He wanted to gather her children “as a hen gathers her chicks under her wings,” but “you were not willing.” That passage is not specifically teaching about losing salvation. But it does show us something important about this imagery: God’s ability and desire to gather and protect does not mean human unwillingness suddenly becomes impossible.
The same distinction helps me understand John 10. I do not believe something can overpower Jesus and rip me from His hand. His hand is secure. But that does not require me to believe that Scripture’s repeated warnings about turning away, refusing to abide, or departing through unbelief suddenly have no meaning. In fact, Jesus’ description of His sheep is worth hearing again: “My sheep hear My voice…and they follow Me.” He does not describe His sheep merely by something that happened to them years ago. He describes an ongoing relationship between the sheep and their Shepherd. They hear Him. They are known by Him. They follow Him.
In John 15 He repeatedly tells His disciples to “abide in Me.” Hebrews warns believers not to develop “an evil heart of unbelief in departing from the living God” (Hebrews 3:12). Colossians speaks about being presented holy and blameless “if indeed you continue in the faith” (Colossians 1:23). Romans says, “you stand by faith,” and then warns about unbelief (Romans 11:20–22).
So I do not have a problem with John 10 at all. Nobody can snatch me out of Jesus’ hand. I believe that completely. My disagreement begins when we make “no one can snatch them” mean “therefore no believer can ever willfully turn away from Christ.” Those are not exactly the same statement.
John 10 gives me tremendous assurance about the strength of my Shepherd. The warning passages remind me of my need to continue following that Shepherd. I do not stay with Jesus because His hand is weak and He desperately needs my help keeping me saved. I remain because He is the One in whom my life and salvation are found. I trust His hand. I listen for His voice. I follow my Shepherd. And I take seriously His command to abide. No one can snatch me from Him. But Scripture still tells me: remain in Him.
Romans 8:38–39 — Nothing Can Separate Us From God’s Love
Romans 8:38–39 tells us that neither death nor life, angels nor principalities, things happening now or things coming in the future, nor “any other created thing” can separate us from the love of God found in Christ Jesus.
Again, amen. This passage should give Christians tremendous comfort. There is no circumstance powerful enough to make God stop being who He is. Death cannot separate us from His love. Spiritual powers cannot separate us from His love. Persecution cannot separate us from His love. Nothing in creation can overpower God and tear His people away from Him.
But again, Paul is talking about the strength and faithfulness of God’s love, not giving permission for us to dismiss every warning about unbelief and apostasy. The same Paul who wrote Romans 8 also wrote Romans 11, where he says “you stand by faith” and warns about being cut off through unbelief.
So I believe Romans 8 exactly as it is written. Nothing in creation can overpower God’s love for us. But that does not mean I have to turn around and say that abandoning faith in Christ is therefore impossible.
Ephesians 1:13–14 — Sealed With the Holy Spirit
Another passage often used is Ephesians 1:13–14. Paul says that after hearing the gospel and believing, Christians were “sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise,” who is the guarantee of our inheritance.
This is a beautiful truth. The Holy Spirit really does seal believers. His presence in us is God’s pledge that we belong to Him and that He intends to bring His saving work to completion. Where I disagree is when we add something the passage itself does not say: “Because we are sealed, a believer could completely abandon Christ and remain saved regardless.” Paul does not say that. In fact, later in the same letter Paul tells these same believers, “Do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, by whom you were sealed for the day of redemption” (Ephesians 4:30). So being sealed did not mean Paul stopped caring about how believers continued to live. Being sealed should give us confidence in God’s faithfulness, not confidence that rejecting Christ could never matter.
John 6:37–40 — Jesus Will Lose Nothing the Father Gives Him
Jesus says in John 6 that those the Father gives Him will come to Him, that the one who comes to Him He will never cast out, and that it is the Father’s will that He should lose nothing that has been given to Him. Again, this should bring believers tremendous comfort. Jesus is not looking for an excuse to throw you away. If you are struggling, repentant, coming to Christ, and depending upon Him, you do not need to live terrified that Jesus suddenly wants nothing to do with you. That is not the picture Jesus gives us.
But once again, the question we have been studying is different. We are not asking whether Jesus will throw away someone who is coming to Him or abiding in Him. We are asking what Scripture says about someone who ultimately refuses to continue coming, abandons faith, denies Christ, and turns away. The promise that Jesus will not cast away those who come to Him does not erase the warnings given to those who do turn away from Him.
Philippians 1:6 — He Will Complete the Work He Began
Philippians 1:6 says Paul is confident that “He who has begun a good work in you will complete it until the day of Jesus Christ.”
This is another beautiful promise about God’s faithfulness. God does not begin working in us because He plans on abandoning us halfway through. But notice the context. Paul is talking about believers who had been continuing in “fellowship in the gospel from the first day until now.” Paul sees what God has been doing in them and expresses confidence that God will continue His work. I believe that. God is faithful to finish what He begins. But God’s faithfulness does not require us to pretend Scripture never warns believers about abandoning faith. The fact that God is faithful does not mean human’s are nor that chosen unbelief suddenly becomes meaningless.
Romans 8:29–30 — Foreknown, Predestined, Called, Justified, Glorified
Romans 8:29–30 speaks about those God foreknew being predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son, then called, justified, and glorified. This is sometimes called the “golden chain” of salvation. My understanding is that God predetermined the destiny of those who are in Christ. Those who belong to Christ are destined to be conformed to His image and ultimately glorified with Him. I do not believe this passage says that God chose certain individuals to salvation in such a way that any willful falling away or apostasy becomes impossible for them while choosing everyone else for destruction. That is a theological interpretation placed upon the passage. Romans 8 and Romans 11 were written by the same Paul. Whatever we believe about predestination must leave room for Paul’s own warning that people stand by faith and must not turn toward unbelief.
1 Peter 1:3–5 — Kept by the Power of God
First Peter 1 describes believers as having an incorruptible inheritance reserved in heaven and says they are “kept by the power of God through faith for salvation.” This verse actually expresses the balance I have been talking about throughout this entire teaching. God keeps us. We do not keep ourselves saved through our own strength. We are not hanging over hell by our fingertips desperately hoping we can behave well enough to make it into heaven. God’s power is what keeps us. But notice the entire phrase: “kept by the power of God through faith.” Faith is still there.
That fits perfectly with what we have already seen. We are saved through faith. Romans says we stand by faith. Colossians says continue in the faith. Hebrews tells us to hold fast. Peter says God’s power keeps us through faith. God’s keeping power and our continuing faith are not enemies.
1 John 2:19 — “They Were Never Really Saved”
This is probably one of the most important verses we need to address because it is often used as the answer to almost every warning about falling away.
First John 2:19 says, “They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would have continued with us.”
The argument is usually: “See? Anyone who leaves the faith was never actually saved. If they had truly been saved, they would have stayed.” But we need to pay attention to who John is talking about. In the surrounding passage, John is talking about people he calls antichrists. These people had departed from the Christian community and were denying the truth about Jesus. John says these particular people had demonstrated by leaving that they were never truly of them. And I have absolutely no problem saying that.
Some people who leave Christianity were never genuinely saved in the first place. Some people attend church, know Christian language, participate outwardly, and never actually surrender their lives to Christ. But that does not automatically mean every person described anywhere in Scripture as falling away was never saved. That is where I disagree with using 1 John 2:19 as the answer to everything.
Hebrews 6 describes people as “partakers of the Holy Spirit.” Hebrews 10 talks about someone “sanctified” by the blood of the covenant. Colossians tells people “now He has reconciled” them and then tells those same people to continue in faith. Jesus talks about branches “in Me” that are commanded to abide.
We should allow each passage to speak for itself. First John 2 proves that false converts exist. It does not automatically prove that every warning about genuine falling away elsewhere in Scripture must secretly be describing false converts.
1 John 5:11–13 — You Can Know You Have Eternal Life
John tells believers that God has given us eternal life through His Son and says he writes these things so that they “may know” they have eternal life. I absolutely believe Christians can know they are saved. Rejecting Once Saved, Always Saved does not mean waking up every morning wondering, “Am I still saved? Did I lose salvation yesterday? Did I get it back this morning?” That is not what I believe.
My assurance is in Jesus Christ. If I am trusting Him, abiding in Him, following Him, and continuing in faith, I do not need to live terrified that one sin or one failure has suddenly erased my salvation. But knowing that I have eternal life in Christ is different from believing I could completely reject Christ tomorrow and somehow continue possessing eternal life apart from Him. John himself repeatedly talks about abiding. The same John who says we can know we have eternal life also tells believers to remain in the Son and in the Father. Those truths do not contradict each other.
Jude 24 — God Is Able to Keep Us
Jude praises God as the One who is “able to keep you from stumbling, and to present you faultless before the presence of His glory.”
Again, amen. God is able to keep us. My position does not require me to believe God is weak. The question has never been whether God has enough power to keep someone saved. The question is whether Scripture allows for someone to choose to fall away and reject Him.
Interestingly, earlier in the same letter Jude tells believers to “keep yourselves in the love of God” (Jude 21), and then ends by praising God as the One who is able to keep them. That is a beautiful picture of the balance we have seen throughout Scripture. We continue with Him while depending completely upon His power to sustain us.
Romans 11:29 — The Gifts and Calling of God Are Irrevocable
Romans 11:29 says, “For the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable.”
Paul is not talking about God refusing to revoke an individual Christian’s salvation. He is talking about Israel and God’s faithfulness to His covenant purposes for Israel.
The verses immediately before it make that clear. In Romans 11:28 Paul says concerning Israel, “Concerning the gospel they are enemies for your sake, but concerning the election they are beloved for the sake of the fathers.” Then comes verse 29: “For the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable.” The word “for” connects Paul’s statement directly to what he has just said. Israel remains beloved “for the sake of the fathers,” and God’s gifts and calling are irrevocable. Paul is talking about God’s faithfulness to what He promised and purposed concerning Israel.
That fits the question Paul has been dealing with throughout Romans 9–11. Israel’s widespread rejection of Christ raised an obvious question: Has God’s Word failed? Has God completely rejected the people He called? Are His promises to Israel finished because so many Israelites are presently in unbelief? Paul repeatedly answers no. Romans 11:1 asks, “Has God cast away His people?” and Paul answers, “Certainly not!”
So when Paul eventually says “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable,” he is assuring his readers that Israel’s present unbelief has not made God unfaithful to His promises. God has not changed His character, forgotten His purposes, or decided His previous calling meant nothing.
This becomes even clearer because of what Paul says immediately afterward. Romans 11:30–31 compares the Gentiles and Israel. The Gentiles were once disobedient but received mercy, while Israel is presently in disobedience, with Paul still looking toward mercy. His entire argument is about God’s continuing redemptive purposes despite human unbelief.
And this is where pulling Romans 11:29 out of context creates a problem. Earlier in this same chapter, Paul has already said that natural branches were “broken off” because of unbelief (Romans 11:20). He tells the Gentile, “you stand by faith.” Then he warns, “Do not be haughty, but fear.” He continues by saying God’s goodness is toward them “if you continue in His goodness. Otherwise you also will be cut off” (Romans 11:22).
Then Paul says something equally important about Israel in verse 23: “And they also, if they do not continue in unbelief, will be grafted in, for God is able to graft them in again.”
So look at the entire picture Paul gives us within one chapter. Some branches were broken off because of unbelief. Gentiles presently stand by faith. Gentiles are warned to continue. Those who were broken off can be grafted in again if they do not continue in unbelief. And then Paul says God’s gifts and calling are irrevocable. Those statements cannot contradict one another.
That means “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” cannot reasonably mean “unbelief no longer matters once someone has previously been connected to God.” Paul has just spent part of the chapter saying the opposite. Unbelief is exactly why branches were broken off, and faith is exactly how the Gentile presently stands.
What is irrevocable is God’s faithfulness to His calling and redemptive purposes. Israel’s unbelief does not make God unfaithful. God has not forgotten the patriarchs or abandoned everything He promised. That is why Paul can simultaneously warn about unbelief and declare God’s calling irrevocable. God’s faithfulness remains even when human beings are unfaithful.
This actually fits the larger point of this teaching beautifully. God’s faithfulness and the necessity of continuing in faith are not opposites. Romans 11 contains both truths right beside each other. God remains faithful to His purposes, while human beings are still warned about unbelief.
So I absolutely believe Romans 11:29: “The gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable.” God does not change His mind because His plans failed. He does not abandon His promises because people are difficult. His covenant faithfulness is dependable.
But I do not believe we can take that sentence out of a chapter about Israel, Gentiles, faith, unbelief, branches being broken off, branches being grafted in, and God’s continuing purposes for Israel, and turn it into a blanket statement that an individual believer can never later abandon faith and be cut off. In fact, the chapter itself warns against exactly that kind of presumption.
God’s calling is faithful. God’s promises are faithful. God’s purposes are faithful. But Paul still says: “You stand by faith.” And because you stand by faith, “do not be haughty, but fear.”
2 Timothy 2:13 — “He Remains Faithful”
We already covered this passage earlier, but it is worth mentioning again because people sometimes quote only one part: “If we are faithless, He remains faithful; He cannot deny Himself.” That can sound like Paul is saying, “Even if you completely abandon Christ, He will save you anyway.” But the verse immediately before it says, “If we deny Him, He also will deny us.” We cannot use “He remains faithful” to erase “He also will deny us.” Christ remains faithful because He remains true to Himself. He remains faithful to His promises, His character, and His warnings. Our unfaithfulness does not cause Jesus to contradict Himself.
So, Are We Secure?
Yes. Absolutely. I believe Christians have tremendous security in Christ.
Nobody can overpower Jesus and steal us from Him. Satan cannot snatch us from His hand. Death cannot separate us from God’s love. Spiritual powers cannot defeat Him. The Holy Spirit truly seals believers. Jesus receives those who come to Him. God is able to keep us. Our salvation is built upon His grace rather than our ability to behave perfectly. That is biblical security.
Where I disagree with Once Saved, Always Saved is the idea that because all of those things are true, continuing in faith no longer matters. I cannot read Jesus saying “abide in Me” and conclude abiding does not matter. I cannot read Paul saying “continue in the faith” and conclude continuing does not matter. I cannot read Hebrews warning about “departing from the living God” and decide departure is impossible. I cannot read “if we deny Him, He also will deny us” and decide denial has no eternal consequence. I cannot read “you stand by faith” followed by “otherwise you also will be cut off” and conclude future unbelief cannot matter. And I do not believe we should use God’s promises to erase God’s warnings. That is where I land after looking at both sides.
I believe in security in Christ. I do not believe Scripture teaches security apart from Christ. I do not believe salvation disappears every time a Christian sins. I do not believe struggling means you are unsaved. I do not believe weakness automatically means someone has fallen away. Christians stumble. Christians struggle. Christians can fail terribly and repent. Peter denied Jesus and was restored.
That is very different from apostasy; ultimately rejecting Christ, abandoning faith, settling into unbelief, and refusing to return. This entire teaching has been about that distinction. The promises of Scripture tell me how faithful God is. The warnings of Scripture tell me not to presume upon that faithfulness while turning away from Him. I do not have to choose one group of verses and throw away the other. I need both.
The promises tell me I do not have to live terrified.
The warnings tell me I should never become spiritually careless.
The promises tell me Christ is able to keep me.
The warnings tell me to continue with Christ.
The promises tell me nobody can snatch me from His hand.
The warnings tell me not to harden my own heart in unbelief.
That is not a contradiction.
THAT IS RELATIONSHIP.My confidence is not in my ability to live perfectly. My confidence is not in how many good works I can perform. My confidence is not even in how tightly I think I can hold onto Jesus.
My confidence is in Jesus Christ.
And because my confidence is in Him, I want to take seriously everything He tells me to do:
